tripleC 6(2): 88-104, 2008
ISSN 1726-670X
http://www.triple-c.at
CC: Creative Commons License, 2008.
Public participatory GIS in community-based disaster risk
reduction
Randall B. Kemp
Information School, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington, USA, rbkemp@u.washington.edu
Abstract: Natural hazards, such as earthquakes and floods, result in disasters for several reasons. One of the important
factors is reducing risk before an incident arises. Such efforts are commonly termed disaster risk reduction (DRR). DRR is
the process and engagement of a local community to explore factors of risk and implement methods, practices, and even
cultural change, which will reduce the probability that a natural hazard will result in a severe disaster.
In this paper I explore the applicability of public participatory GIS (PPGIS) technologies into DRR efforts. Geographic
information systems (GIS) function as an electronic spatial data storage, mapping, and analysis tool compromised of
software, hardware, and data inputs. GIS can produce simple maps as well as complicated analysis based on several data
sources (or layers). Like standard participatory research methods, PPGIS incorporates end users, research subjects, and
researchers into a collaborative environment where GIS are structured under the guidance of both the expert and the
novice. One intended result are GIS appropriate to the needs and uses of a given community, with specific attention to the
cultural underpinnings of that community.
Introducing PPGIS tools into community-based DRR is not a neutral effort. The information and communication technologies
(ICT) embedded in GIS can both aid the DRR efforts as well as impact the community in unintended ways. ICTs may be
common in communities engaged in DRR efforts so the introduction of PPGIS may have minimal impact. What are the
societal ramifications, however, of PPGIS methods in DRR efforts when ICTs are a relatively new aspect of a given
community? What are the communication methods pertinent to PPGIS in the DRR context? How does the ICT literature
address PPGIS methods? The paper addresses these and other influences of ICT on societies prone to natural hazards.
Keywords: PPGIS, natural hazards, disaster risk reduction, information organization
Acknowledgement: Generous thanks to the anonymous review and helpful feedback from the ICT&S Doctoral Students‟
Meeting colleagues.
he numbers of people impacted by
natural hazards is showing an upward
trend. More people are displaced and put
into health risk from floods, earthquakes, and
drought. Humanitarian actors seek to reduce
these risks through development strategies
and community-based exercises to assess
disaster risk. A key input to these exercises is
accurate and extensive information from
which communities might make decisions,
changes, and plans for moving forward.
1. Introduction
This research project explores the
information organization practices of a local
community in a developing country by
deploying a public participatory geographic
information system to aid the collection,
organization, and use of information with a
special focus on geographic information. The
goal of the work is to make a contribution to
the growing literature around disaster risk
reduction and the use of information and
communication technologies (ICT) to support
community-based risk reduction efforts.
The paper first sets out the research
questions and goals of the project along with
a brief overview of suggested methods. The
next sections then introduce definitions of
information, information organization, and
information science. These definitions set the
tripleC 6(2): 88-104, 2008 89
CC: Creative Commons License, 2008.
stage and place the work in a particular
discipline. Geographic information is then
defined and described, along with geographic
information science.
Other key themes are then explored. These
themes, in order of presentation, are natural
hazards, humanitarian relief organizations,
and disaster risk reduction (DRR). A brief
survey of additional information organization
and geographic information science research
is provided.
Before the concluding summary, a detailed
example of the possible methods is provided.
The paper ends with a concluding summary of
the work as well as a short section on
potential future research.
The realm of this research project centers
on the overlap of information organization
patterns of a community-based DRR effort.
The type of community in question, briefly, is
a small, localized community prone to natural
hazards. In this context I seek to address the
following research questions.
How does the community classify its
information once it is collected? That is,
what are the steps the community takes to
organize, label, or otherwise assign
significance to the information?
What is the resultant organization and
classification scheme based on the
community-based steps of collecting and
organizing?
How does geographic information factor
into classification steps and scheme? How
pervasive across the organizing scheme
are geographic concepts?
What affordances and limitations do ICTs
either natively existent or introduced during
the research (such as public participatory
geographic information systems (PPGIS),
see below) contribute to the classification?
If indeed information is power and well-
organized information aids the decision
making process then exploring how
communities prone to negative impacts from
natural hazards may highlight where local
capacity for information gathering and
organization can positively reduce risk to
disasters. Conversely, the research may
highlight missing information and give
evidence to those agencies, governments,
and people with the power to generate or
provide information to local communities.
Utilizing ICTs in the research project, as a
means to aid collection and organization
particularly of geographic information, may be
a powerful tool to draw out information
patterns and organization schemes. ICTs, on
the other hand, may prove to be a significant
hindrance in the collection and organization of
information. The goal of the project, then, is
not to impose ICTs on the participants but to
explore the value of such tools for a given
community.
A primary goal of the research is to
empower a local community to better assess
its natural hazard proclivities and thereby
move towards solutions for reducing that risk.
The particular structures of information
organization and ICTs are scaffolding upon
which the community may achieve these
results. The research project will contribute to
the ongoing conversations in the humanitarian
sector regarding beneficiary information
needs and the use of technological tools in
development.
In order to address the suggested research
questions from above, I aim to explore how a
small, local community in a developing region
might be supported by their use of PPGIS in
the DRR efforts with a special focus on the
organization of geographic information.
I define a small, local community as one
that is bounded by some geographical
markers such as a watershed and no more
than a population of 5,000 persons. The
community will be in a developing country,
preferably in a Spanish-speaking region (due
to my own rudimentary knowledge of the
language). Locating possible communities will
come through networking among current
contacts in humanitarian relief and
development organizations currently enacting
DRR projects. I will then seek to work with a
variety of people from the community in a
small team comprised of local leaders as well
as those whose voices are not often heard
within that community.
After identifying a community willing to
partner in the project, I will devise exercises
using GIS pertinent to the region and culture. I
expect that this will include both low- and hi-
90 Randall B. Kemp
CC: Creative Commons License, 2008.
tech ICTs such as drawing maps on paper as
well as walking around with global positioning
system (GPS) devices. These exercises with
the community will have as their goal the
elucidation of the types of information the
community collects in its DRR efforts, the
sources of information, how the information is
organized, and how the information is then
incorporated into decision-making. One
exercise might be a set of “what” questions to
draw out what kinds of information is
collected: what do you need to know about
topography? for instance.
Assessing the types of information could
then flow into an exercise of gathering specific
instances of information into GIS application.
If the gathered information on first blush did
not have a spatial component, another set of
questions could be asked to explore how a
piece of information might actually be tied to a
specific place within or affecting the
community. At first the collection of
information might be straightforward and
logically be placed in the spatial database.
After the gathering of more data, however, it
may be necessary to build together a more
structured and organized spatial repository.
Another exercise could entail the making of
a map on a poster-sized piece of paper of
where the community perceives their
boundaries to be. As a follow-on exercise, the
team could then plot, using a GPS, the
boundaries by walking the perimeter of the
boundary. A comparison could then be made
of the similarities between the original map
and the plotted boundaries to see how the
team organizes what is in and what is outside
of their community.
The significant power of GIS is their ability
to layer and analyze data over a defined
space. Consequently, another step in the
PPGIS efforts potentially undertaken in this
project is to explore with the team, once data
has been collected, the interactions of various
data points with one another. I expect this
phase of the participatory research will require
some collaborative hardware and software in
order for the whole team to look at and ask
questions of the data using the computer
tools. The group could be shown some simple
analytical possibilities then solicit questions
from the team that they want to ask of the
data. I would then ask questions of the team
regarding the organization of information.
A step I would take at the start of the
research with the local community is to ask
them individually how they organized
information for their DRR efforts. I would ask
them to identify specific categories of
information they collect along with definitions
for those categories. I would also ask them to
describe how the various categories connect
with each other as like-dislike, in a hierarchy,
etc. Towards the end of the participatory
exercises, then, we as a team would seek to
draw out the categories of information as
illuminated in the GIS and compare them to
the original categories provided by the
individual team members.
Since I am exploring how ICTs, specifically
GIS, act as an affordance or impediment to
information gathering, organization, and use, I
will engage the team in reflective exercises
about the perceived aid or detriment of GIS in
the DRR effort. I will ask for examples and
stories from the team to corroborate their
analysis.
The above questions and exercises remain
possibilities at this juncture of the research.
Participatory methods are both planned and
spontaneous depending on how the group
moves the exploration along. I am not
attempting to prescribe exercises that must be
completed but rather options to be used in
case circumstances warrant.
In the following sections I set out the
background literature, definitions of terms,
and description of the fields in question.
1.1. Information
In this section definitions of information are
provided as a means to frame the research
around further issues of information
organization. Additionally, a picture of
information science is given as the home
discipline for the research.
1.1.1. Definitions of Information
First off, there is no one accepted definition
of information, even within information science
(IS) (Buckland, 1991). Prior to the rise of IS as
a named field, MacKay (1953, p. 62) defined
information as “that which adds to a
tripleC 6(2): 88-104, 2008 91
CC: Creative Commons License, 2008.
representation of what is known or believed or
alleged to be the case.” Buckland (1991, p.
356) made famous in the IS community the
“information-as-thing” notation, under the
belief that “we are unable to say confidently of
anything that is could not be information.” The
“thing” could be a scream of terror or an
antelope, for instance. The critical point in his
argument centers on an object or event being
informative, and this can be left to a matter of
individual judgment. Writing later, Buckland
(1999) uses an appropriate metaphor when
he writes, “I am increasingly impressed by the
complexity of the „landscape‟ of Information
Science,” and includes, as an example under
“many specialized genres,” geographical
information systems.
Taking a cue from Edwin Parker, Bates
(2006) defines information as the patterns of
organization of matter and energy. Further,
Bates claims that these patterns are not
inherently meaningful, but can be assigned
meaning by people. From patterns to value,
Losee (1997) wrote, “Information is produced
by all processes and it is the values of
characteristics in the processes‟ output that
are information.”
Just because information is recorded –
recorded information is what some consider
the domain of IS (see more below) – does not
indeed qualify it as information. This claim,
made by Floridi (2004, 2005), posits that
misinformation is not really information at all
because it is not meaningful or well formed.
But requiring information to be useful
information is not a stance Losee (1997, p.
257) is willing to accept because it “excludes
the information carried by a subatomic particle
which is not sensed by a cognitive process.”
Important for the discussion at hand is the
notion of embedded information. Such
information is left behind by animals (and
humans) in the environment. Bates (2006)
uses the example of a spider building its web.
Elsewhere, Bates (2005) articulates her notion
of information and its importance for IS: “I
have long felt that to succeed in the process
of developing a broadly applicable,
encompassing understanding of information
for our field, we must begin at the physical
and biological levels and move up to the
cultural, social, cognitive and aesthetic.”
For the purposes of this paper, I define
information as the substance of an idea or
thing which represents that idea or thing; it
communicates something to the person; and it
need not be recorded to be information
because information is inherent rather than
realized through some contingency of its
packaging. Related to the project at hand,
then, this definition can encompass the local
knowledge of community members as well as
the technical geographic information gleaned
from computer devices. The value of the local
knowledge is not in its collection, packaging,
or recording, but it inherently is information.
The act of recording it on a map does not
make it information.
1.1.2. Information Organization
Information organization (IO) makes explicit
the relationships among information objects,
primarily by “bringing all the same information
together” (Svenonius, 2001, p. 10). A simple
example is the grouping a music lover
employs to categorize her record collection by
genres such as classical, jazz, blues, and
gospel. Some relationship then exists for all
the records in the classical category. IO is the
task of grouping, arranging, and representing
information to draw connections and
relationships among information so that
conclusions and new knowledge emerge from
these connections (Dahlberg, 2006, p. 12).
These connections highlight similarities as
well as differences, as the rudimentary
example of music grouping shows.
Additionally, IO intends to engender a
common communication platform built around
the connections such that the explicit linkages
facilitate understanding of ideas among a
variety of people (Albrechtsen and Jacob,
1998). IO (also known as Knowledge
Representation or Knowledge Organization) is
primarily a subfield within IS but is not an
exclusive member of that discipline, because
the activities and frameworks of IO cut across
other disciplines, including geographic
information science (GISci).
The domain of IO arises from certain
questions articulated by both researchers and
practitioners. Some of these questions
include, what characteristics of object (or
concept) A are shared with object B? In the
92 Randall B. Kemp
CC: Creative Commons License, 2008.
making of lists of any kind, what are the
important skeletal frameworks upon which
humans organize? What do we do with a new
idea that has no place in an existing
organization structure? Can we devise a
scheme so hospitable, that all concepts and
objects have a place?
Intuitively, we all group and classify. People
of all professions and cultures build piles on
their desks, categorize, and otherwise
inherently classify things based on
organizational structures, unconscious
leanings, and cultural practices (Bowker and
Star, 1999). Going one step further, the
accepted categories we all take for granted
are not quite so predictable and uniform as we
might think (Lakoff, 1987). In fact, one-size-
fits-all classification schemes tend to fail
(Albrechtsen and Jacob, 1998). IO exists
because of these factors: humans categorize,
we think we know what categories signify, and
we pursue universal categorization schemes
even when they do not satisfy.
IO, in short, is grouping like information
objects together. It is the drawing of
intentional links within and across these
groupings. There may or may not be a
purpose or goal in the organizing. The
groupings do, however, provide an
opportunity to then tell a story about the
information objects and how they are
grouped, which can be important in the
decision-making process. The organization of
information by the community members in this
project, noted in the early phases of the
suggested activities detailed below will reveal
itself as the members discuss their
perceptions of their geography. The groupings
they make, taken on their own and in
conjunction with information organized by
GIS, may result in new observations for both
the community members and interpretation of
GIS data. That is, the linkages articulated by
the community members may be a more
accurate representation of reality than the
linkages arrived at by computer algorithms.
1.1.3. Information Science
Just as the right definition of information is
elusive, there is no consensus on what IS is
(Zins, 2006). Adding yet another dimension to
terminology (e.g., what are the differences, if
any, between data, information, and
knowledge), Zins argues that “information
science” should be “knowledge science.”
According to Houser (1988) the term
“information science” gained popularity in the
1960s Schrader (1984), and has most often
been defined as the “study of the gathering,
organizing, storing, retrieving, and
dissemination of information” (Bates, 1999, p.
1044). In a classic definition of the field, Borko
(1968, p. 4) articulates the essence of IS
research: “investigates the properties, and
behavior of information, the use and
transmission of information, and the
processing of information for optimal storage
and retrieval.”
There is debate over whether IS concerns
itself only with recorded information. Bates
(1999) states that the domain of IS is primarily
(but not solely) recorded information. “The
special focus of LIS is on documented
knowledge produced by human beings in
some kind of documents of potential use to
other human being” (Hjørland, 2003, p. 93).
On the other hand, “Information is more than
recorded words and languages; it is images,
music, light, any entity that interacts as largely
as in concert with the universe or as minutely
as subatomic particles” (Norton, 2000, p. 5)
One important aspect of IS tied to the
human side is that of communication. Made
famous by Shannon & Weaver is the idea of
sending and receiving messages. IS has
taken communication (an equally vague term
as is information (cf. Saracevic, 1992) to
heart.
The definition of IS I employ for this paper
is that it is the study of the collection,
organization, and re-use of information. For
the project at hand, then, each of those
characteristics is at play.
1.2. Geographic Information
Now that information, information
organization, and information science have
been defined and explored, the concepts of
geographic information and geographic
information science are articulated. The
research uses geographic information and the
associated ICTs familiar in that realm to
further frame and narrows the research
space.
tripleC 6(2): 88-104, 2008 93
CC: Creative Commons License, 2008.
When humanitarian actors, such as
nongovernmental organizations (NGOs), local
governments, and the United Nations (UN),
respond to an emergency such as a disaster
or a more protracted complex emergency,
they require information about the context and
situation of specific locations in order to best
assess and respond with aid. Ideally these
multiple actors (and even multiple units within
a given organization) share information in
order to best alleviate suffering and quicken
the arrival of stability and humane conditions.
Much of this information, quite naturally, has
spatial attributes. Spatial attributes include a
simple location, such as a given village in
Pakistan, or a specific section of coastline
within Mississippi or Indonesia.
1.2.1. Geographic Information Science
Definitions and Background
Geographic information (GI) has been
defined as “information about features and
phenomena located in the vicinity of the
surface of the Earth” (Goodchild et al., 1999,
p. 732), including human activities that occur
on it (Goodchild, 2000). GI is then a subset of
spatial information, where “spatial,” in contrast
to “geo,” is not tied to the earth, e.g., the
human body, an automobile, or the universe
(Goodchild, 2001). GI is minimally a list of two
variables: a location in space-time and
attributes associated with that space
(Goodchild et al., 1999). An example from an
IS perspective supports the same definition:
“GI is defined by the use of spatial and
temporal referencing to characterize
information” (Raper et al., 2002, p. 39).
Geographic information science emerged
as a scientific field in the late 1980s (Mark et
al., 1999) and it contains the components of
data collection, data modeling, structuring,
and analysis of GI (Goodchild, 1992). “GISci
… is concerned with geographic concepts, the
primitive elements used to describe, analyze,
model, reason about, and make decisions on
phenomena distributed on the surface of the
earth” (Wright et al., 1997, p. 357, emphasis
in original).
GISci emerged from the study of
geographic information systems (GIS) (used
in the plural), which function as an electronic
spatial data storage, mapping, and analysis
tool. GIS appeared in the 1960s (Goodchild,
2003) and then later became an object of
study as researchers sought to develop a
science around the tool. The types of
questions GISci asks include: How can GI be
represented? How can GI be quantified, and
what metrics of GI measure its volume
(Duckham et al., 2003, p. 1)? How is GI best
collected and organized? How can
relationships among GI be signified?
1.3. Natural Hazards
The next three sections define key
concepts in the research space. These
concepts sit primarily in the humanitarian
relief and development sector and are natural
hazards, humanitarian relief organizations,
and disaster risk reduction. All three are
critical to the research, the research
questions, and the community-based nature
of the research.
Natural processes such as earthquakes,
tsunamis, and hurricanes comprise a subset
of the causes for landscape change. These
environments, one might assume from the
sheer number of news reports about
devastating disasters, appear to be facing an
upswing in catastrophic events impacting both
natural landscapes and human populations.
The evidence for such an increase in the
intensity of disasters and the consequences
on human life and property is mixed. Those
killed by disasters between 1917 and 1932
surpassed 3 million in six different years,
largely due to pandemics (cf. EM-DAT: The
OFDA/CRED International Disaster Database.
Université Catholique de Louvain, Brussels,
Belgium, available at http://www.emdat.be). In
contrast, no year since 1960 has recorded
more than 600,000 deaths. When comparing
the mean number of deaths over ten-year
spans in the last 40 years, the death count is
lower in the most recent decade than in the
first or second decade. The mean number of
deaths due to disasters for 1966–1975 was
198,864; 1976–1985 was 103,751; 1986–
1995 was 46,068; and 1996–2005 was
88,896.
The figures reveal a different pattern when
the number of people affected – the
homeless, jobless, sick – by disasters is
counted. The trend is decidedly increasing,
94 Randall B. Kemp
CC: Creative Commons License, 2008.
even if the counts for individual years rise and
fall. The mean number of persons affected per
year from 1996 to 2005 was 240,250,791.
Such a staggering number only obscures the
myriad factors influencing its growth such as
an increasing global population, higher-
density populations, and increased
populations living in environmentally unstable
systems, among others. What the number
does suggest, however, is the need for a
concerted effort to alleviate suffering from
disasters to so many people.
The estimated monetary damages
sustained during given years show a
decidedly upward trend. Between 1996 and
2005 the mean estimated monetary cost for
disasters runs to $US 65.6bn, which does not
include the estimated cost from the Kobé,
Japan, earthquake in 1995 of $US 121bn.
1.4. Humanitarian Relief Organizations
Into this context rises the humanitarian
relief field with all its policies, organizations,
guiding documents, and goodwill.
Humanitarian relief organizations hold as a
significant goal the alleviation of suffering on
the part of disaster survivors and others
affected by complex emergencies. These
organizations supply local people with food,
shelter, and health care by sending personnel
and working with pre-planned organizations
already on the ground in vulnerable areas.
Jurisdiction questions concerning land,
data, and reputation are significant in the
humanitarian relief context. Multiple actors
participate in humanitarian relief operations.
During the tsunami relief efforts governments
from around the world pledged monetary
support as well as personnel transports into
Indonesia and Sri Lanka. In addition, the UN,
the European Union, and other multi-lateral
organizations provided services of various
kinds. On top of this, literally hundreds of
NGOs, some newly formed after the disaster,
inundated villages. Where relief operations
became chaotic due to the sheer numbers of
NGOs, some NGOs attempted to organize the
many players while others found people
under-served and refocused energies there
(IFRC, 2005). All this to say, jurisdiction
questions in such a, potentially, contentious
environment beg for, at a minimum,
procedures designed to increase the
efficiency of coordination, which may involve
data management capabilities and policies on
standards (not only for data coordination but
for other practical aspects of relief efforts such
as food and shelter). Second, beyond
coordination, issues of legal and de facto
jurisdiction in times of disaster operations
belong in the hands of international
humanitarian law experts.
Humanitarian action (HA) is the work of
assisting communities facing short- and long-
term crises, including disasters, complex
emergencies like a protracted civil war,
economic deprivation, and infringements on
basic human rights. Humanitarians seek to
support what Sen (1999) champions: people
have a “freedom to” in the economic, social,
and political spheres of their lives. HA typically
includes work in the major phases of the
disaster cycle: mitigation (actions designed to
reduce the impact of future disasters),
preparation, response, and recovery
(Alexander, 2002). A more familiar term than
HA is “humanitarian relief and development”
(HRD), which demarcates too precisely
between something called “relief” and
something called “development,” when in
reality these are stages on a continuum
(Lindenberg and Bryant, 2001).
HA efforts include the delivery of aid such
as food, shelter, and medical care. HA also
includes community involvement with
distressed and vulnerable groups before
disaster strikes with education, shared
planning, and evaluation. HA includes a
robust health assessment of a region and
intentional infrastructure expansion to improve
the health of local populations so they are
better prepared to weather storms, droughts,
and illness. Holistic HA focuses on supporting
locally empowered communities towards
greater resiliency. Another name for this last
concept is disaster risk reduction.
1.5. Disaster Risk Reduction
The combination of humanitarian actors in
a setting of natural hazards is the process of
disaster risk reduction (DRR). DRR is a
framework where practitioners and community
members, ideally, work together to identify
vulnerabilities to natural hazards and change
tripleC 6(2): 88-104, 2008 95
CC: Creative Commons License, 2008.
systems, policies, and habits in order to avoid
or limit the destructive impacts of a hazard
(HPN, 2007; ISDR, 2007).
DRR efforts seek to assess local
conditions, gather data, and then share out
that data with others in order to paint a clearer
picture of natural hazard realities as well as to
educate local communities on the potential
risks (ISDR, 2007, p. 14). There are
challenges, however, to data collection
coverage, methodologies, and reporting
information systems (UNDP, 2004; DFID,
2005).
Climate change research has increased as
a perceived need in order to provide more
detailed data regarding natural hazard risk
(O‟Brien et al., 2006; van Aalst, 2006).
Alongside climate change research,
investigations into the concept and practice of
resilience has also increased (Manyena,
2006; Bosher et al., 2007). Part of the
equation into assessing hazard risk is the use
of community-based disaster preparedness
(see more below on community-based
methods) assisted by information technology
tools (Troy et al., 2007). International aid and
development organizations are investing
resources in the education of communities
about risk to natural hazards (Wamsler, 2006)
and addressing their own challenges with
integrating the DRR framework into their own
efforts (Schipper and Pelling, 2006).
2. Existing Research
At the start of this paper, topics such as
information, information science, and
geographic information were defined and
explored through a literature review. The
following two sections expand on that effort by
further extrapolating particularly pertinent
concepts from information organization and
geographic information science research.
These concepts will help inform the
methodology and analysis of findings.
2.1. Information Organization Research
The IO literature speaks of naïve
classifications as a useful concept. Naïve (or
folk) classification systems are “created by
people who have no particular interest or
training in classificatory design and
implementation” (Beghtol, 2004, p. 19).
Professional classification systems, on the
other hand, are typically predicated on the
world of pre-existing knowledge while naïve
classifications systems concern themselves
with a limited set of knowledge tied to a
particular context and purpose in which they
arise. Additionally, naïve systems are typically
more shallow in their hierarchy and number of
examples than are professional systems
(Beghtol, 2004, p. 21).
Context, as in the journalist‟s who, what,
where, when, why questions, is a significant
construct in IO. The context greatly impacts
the “what” and “why” of an organizing
scheme. “One of the determinants of purpose
for a classification system is generally the
context from which it arose and in which it is
to be used” (Beghtol, 2004, p. 20). Devising
an appropriate classificatory structure is
supported by a collaborative effort of a shared
discourse among information intermediaries
(however defined, e.g., librarians) and the end
users of such a structure (Albrechtsen and
Jacob, 1998; Mai, 2004a). “Given
classifications tend to fit more or less with the
pre-understandings of given (sub)cultures”
(Hjørland, 2002, p. 454). While each user
community is unique, within a given
community heterogeneity also exists (Olson
and Schlegl, 2001). In summary, context
provides foundational building blocks upon
which a useful organization scheme can be
constructed.
Domain-analysis, as used in IO, is one
framework which intentionally focuses on
context as the driving factor of an organization
scheme. “The context of any classification
influences the use and understanding of the
classification to such a degree that the
classification cannot be understood separate
from its context” (Mai, 2002, p. 472), which is
a postmodern view looking at specific
domains rather than at the universe of
knowledge (Mai, 2004a). Domain-analysis ties
the “construction of classification schemes to
the discourse and activities of the users of the
documents” (Mai, 2004a, p. 45). The
language used by the domain in question is
also a vital aspect of any classification work,
work that is “inherently political and value-
laden” (Mai, 2004a, p. 46). The domain-
analysis approach is also critical in the
96 Randall B. Kemp
CC: Creative Commons License, 2008.
indexing (establishing the subject matter of an
object and assigning terms from, typically, a
controlled vocabulary, of documents). What
terms are assigned by the indexer will help or
hinder the users‟ access of that information. If
the indexer takes into consideration the
domain, the communication, essentially,
between the indexer and the user will be
clearer (Mai, 2004b).
The purpose and goal of an organizing
scheme belong in this discussion of context
and are highlighted as a particular aspect of
context because the end goal of a scheme
dramatically affects the design and
implementation of the scheme. It is also true
that classificatory schemes are political tools
because their creation, at least within the
context of an organized group of people,
carries an “agenda of discipline and control
over organization members‟ actions”
(Suchman, 1994, p. 178). If categorizing
people within an organization impose control
on a person‟s responsibility and freedom,
imposing bibliographic control over
documents, as another example, also implies
power over those information objects (Wilson,
1968, p. 6). Both Yates (1989) and the telling
case studies in McPhee (1989) explore
control: one the organizational, the other
nature itself. The purpose of an organizing
structure need not contain the potentially
insidious goal of power. Instead, certain
values, views, and biases subjectively
facilitate or hinder effectiveness of that
structure (Olson, 1998, 2001; Olson and
Schlegl, 2001; Svenonius, 2001; Hjørland,
2002, 2003).
Bowker (1998, p. 255) adroitly highlights
the “relationship between the use of the
classification as an information storage and
retrieval mechanism and its use to encode
multiple political and ethical agendas.” A
scheme cannot, however, classify every
possible bit of relevant information but must
make practical trade-offs (1998, p. 261)
because the system is developed within a
context of organizational practice (1998, p.
264). Additionally, the inflexibility of such
schemes reinforces the existing organization
of information because changes to the
scheme impact the usefulness of previously
organized information (1998, p. 268), even
though schemes might represent one period
in time (with the knowledge known and
recorded at that time) while the world has
changed (Bowker, 1998, p. 271). So, the
context is not only that of the intellectual
content of a given scheme but also the
people, place, and time (1998, p. 273).
Optimistically, the political nature (rigidity) of a
scheme allows the scientific community to
communicate, publish, research, and
otherwise conducts its work due in, at least a
small, part to the scheme at hand (1998, p.
284).
In the family of constructs subsumed under
the heading of context, the notion of a
universal classification scheme can now be
discussed in light of context and purpose of a
scheme. Since information organizing
schemes, to be effective, are contextualized
and created with a purpose, building a
scheme with universal applicability can be
successful only if success is defined as
attending to the lowest common denominator
and completely satisfying only a portion of
users (Mai, 2002, p. 477). The primary
emphasis of contextualization, then, is on
local classification schemes tied to specific
needs and goals of a defined community.
The users of a classification scheme are
considered an important contributor to framing
the context and purpose of the scheme. They
are, therefore, integrated into the design of
the scheme. Although the sentiment that “it is
important to involve the eventual users of the
[HA] information in the design and
development of the collection process”
(Granger, 2000, p. 21) is present in HA
discussions, participation of beneficiaries in
the processes of HA more often than not,
when they touch on information issues, center
on extraction of information from beneficiaries
over and above sharing information with
beneficiaries or incorporating them into the
information collection decisions. One reason
for this is that they are not viewed as users of
information but providers only (IFRC, 2005).
See Cooke and Kothari (2001); Brown et al.
(2003); Eversole (2003) for critical
perspectives – both positive and cautionary –
on participatory research in development. HA
can learn from the IO construct of valuing
local context by including users in the design
and implementation of information
organization schemes so that the scheme will
tripleC 6(2): 88-104, 2008 97
CC: Creative Commons License, 2008.
more appropriately attend to the needs of
beneficiaries.
2.2. GISci Research
Context is also an important construct in
GISci, such that pragmatism and experience
play critical roles in the geographer‟s design
of categories. A geographer is unable to meet
the needs of all other geographers, so must
instead focus on what works in the given
context of categorization (Gray, 1997). Writing
about how to evaluate GI, Raper et al. (2002,
p. 43) remind the reader that “the relevance of
information is task- and context-dependent
and requires a model of information needs.”
Domains, tightly related to context, also
appear in GISci writings as a significant
construct. In attempting to classify vegetation
patterns in areas on the earth where it was
unclear what vegetation was actually present,
Ahlqvist et al. (2003) utilized automatic
reclassification of the vague areas based on
specific domain knowledge. GIS analysis
depends on domain and is appropriately
carried out under the context of the theoretical
and pragmatic characteristics of a given
discipline in a local context (Burrough and
Frank, 1995).
The purpose and goal of collecting and
analyzing GI also fits into the present
discussion of contextualization. The GI in
question, collected within a particular context,
carries with it implicit and explicit value based
substantially on what the recipient of that
information considers being the requirements
and purpose of the effort at hand (Worboys,
2003, p. 33). Transportation flow researchers,
for example, will focus on collecting traffic
patterns, volume of cars, and time-to-
destination information. They may not be so
concerned with roadside vegetation unless
tree and shrub height might be a factor in
traffic speed. Such information collection
would depend on the purpose of the research
effort.
A human-centered approach in GISci, as
opposed to one focused on a tool or on
information itself voids of context, is another
contextual construct. Such an approach
reduces the fragmentation of people and
activities from location and calls for an
integration of a place- and people-based
perspective rather than focusing solely on the
place (Miller, 2003). The human-centered
approach holistically examines the entire
ecology of a location as humans interact in
that context. To cite an obvious example, it
takes into account the human use of a public
park rather than isolating the vegetation, soil,
and precipitation characteristics of the park
while ignoring the human interaction in and
with the park.
The human aspect is vital as well in the
study of networks within social groupings, and
“the analysis of space and place has become
an increasingly pivotal component of social
science research in the past two decades”
(Goodchild et al., 2000, p. 139). Part of this
increase is in the study of multi-faceted
networks of actors, both in business and
social aspects more broadly. These
transnational interconnections are ideal
grounds for exploring space-time research
issues. See Barabási (2002) for a complete
examination of how networks are linked.
Stephenson (2005) favors coordination
without a top-down approach. He instead
suggests social networks are more effective in
garnering trust, which leads to improved
sharing. “It is important to realise that it is not
control, but trust, that can substitute for
certainty [of information]” (Benini, 1997, p.
351). Trust is imperative to knowledge
transfer (Powell, 2003; Sida and Szpak, 2004;
Chua et al., 2007).
Naïve geography takes into consideration
what people believe to be true about GI even
if scientific explanations differ (Goodchild,
2001). The term is not intended to disparage
intellectual capability but to signify instinctive
or spontaneous reflection of how people think
and reason about GI (Egenhofer and Mark,
1995). The focus is then on the common-
sense reasoning about geographic space with
the intention of producing GIS which
incorporate this reasoning in order for the
computer tools to be used by non-
professionals with minimal training.
The technology can also take too much
prominence in GISci. At times, there can be a
focus on hardware over data, with
sophisticated databases and analysis
available without the corresponding robust
data to go with it (Goodchild, 1992).
98 Randall B. Kemp
CC: Creative Commons License, 2008.
Warschauer (2004) raises similar issues in his
helpful book on how ICT may help or actually
exacerbate the digital divide. Even with quality
data, however, another concern is the over-
optimistic use of technology. To counter an
inordinate focus on the technology and to
raise ethical considerations of technology use,
GISci researchers need to admit when
optimism is unfounded and leverage research
showing how this over-optimistic use of
technology impacts equity and representation
(Goodchild et al., 1999, p. 740). Issues of
equity and representation include access to
information and broad representation of
people, ideas, and concepts not in the main
stream.
3. Proposed Methodology
Before outlining proposed research
activities, some background of working with
research subjects and participants who are
refugees is provided. The research activities
suggested below do not include working with
refugees, but some of the characteristics,
warnings, and ethical considerations are
apropos.
After the brief discussion of refugees, public
participatory methods in general are
described as a likely framework for exploring
the research questions above. Public
participatory GIS is then outlined.
3.1. Information Gathering on
Environmental Refugees
The first tactic is to gather more information
about and from the refugees themselves.
Crisp (2003) notes that aid agencies
supposed to alleviate the suffering of refugees
do not possess a full understanding of these
same refugees. Consequently, research on
refugees must begin with a thorough effort to
learn more about them.
Some of the challenges to collecting
information from and about environmental
refugees include their wish to remain
anonymous, possible threats to informants
from host governments, beneficiaries of
humanitarian aid telling researchers what they
want to hear instead of accurate answers,
access to an adequate sampling frame,
validity of information gathered in often
extreme conditions, re-traumatizing survivors,
and the safety of researchers (Jayatilaka and
Muggah, 2004; Uehling, 2004).
Research begins by devising ways to hear
directly from the powerless refugees
themselves, including women and children
(Crisp, 2003). General and one-off surveys
will not suffice as adequate information
gathering tools. Advocating for “hanging out”
with refugees, Rodgers (2004) is critical of the
shallow information gleaned from surveys and
instead argues that investing more time
listening to refugees in their context will be the
best research tactic. Such face-to-face
interaction is vital according to Introna (2002)
rather than mediating access to refugees
through numbers, statistics, or impersonal
surveys. In a well-documented report covering
the information needs of disaster survivors,
several authors provide multiple cases of the
2004 tsunami survivors and their lack of
information (IFRC, 2005).
3.2. Participatory Action Research
Participatory research sets its focus on
incorporating multiple stakeholders in the
formulation and execution of research in more
than a simple survey instrument. Participants,
in this social science research effort, have a
voice in the research efforts, as they are one
of the primary intended beneficiaries of the
research itself. The participants aid the
researcher in generating the questions, the
methods, and even in analysis. There is not
one set participatory method but participatory
methods fall on a spectrum of possibilities. If
the intent of the research is to simply gather
information, participatory methods may add a
greater than necessary overhead to the
project. If, on the other hand, it is desired that
participants also take ownership of some
outcome or share in decision-making, then
participatory methods may be vital
(Freudenberger, 1999, p. 5)
Participatory action methods are used with
the intention of increasing the democratic,
shared nature of research and results (Brown
et al., 2003). Rather than a top-down
imposition of research methods and findings,
the more bottom-up approach of participatory
research seeks to level the playing field, share
power, and highlight marginalized voices
tripleC 6(2): 88-104, 2008 99
CC: Creative Commons License, 2008.
(Walker et al., 2007). The presence of
participatory methods in a research project,
however, does not guarantee shared power.
Some have postulated that participation is just
another form of tyranny (Cooke and Kothari,
2001), that participatory methods maintain the
power structure of those intervening over
those less developed (McKinnon, 2007), that
including the marginalized can actually
hamper their autonomy (O‟Reilly, 2004), that
real participation is often elusive (Eversole,
2003), and that participatory research is full of
paradoxes (Howcroft and Wilson, 2003). It is
also posited that participatory action research
is supported by strong scientific evidence
(Ottosson, 2003).
Utilizing a participatory approach to the
context of disaster risk reduction, taking the
warnings mentioned in the previous
paragraph seriously, results in what a recent
paper calls participatory disaster risk
assessment (PDRA) (Pelling, 2007). The level
of participation in this type of research method
can vary along a spectrum and can be
explored at various stages where community
members might be involved: “initiating the
assessment; identifying what is at risk;
identifying the sources of hazard, vulnerability
or capacity; designing assessment methods;
collecting data; analyzing data; drawing
conclusions for action; acting on results; and
reviewing the usefulness of the assessment”
(Pelling, 2007, p. 379). The community-based
risk assessment process is time consuming
but is also intended to provide a rich,
contextual outcome owned by the participants
themselves.
3.3. Public Participatory GIS
When incorporating context, domain, and
human-centered approaches in GISci, public
participatory GIS (PPGIS) stands out as an
exemplary construct (Harvey and Chrisman,
1998; Nyerges et al., 2002; Sieber, 2003;
Aggett and McColl, 2006; Sieber, 2006). Like
participatory research, PPGIS incorporates
end users, research subjects, and
researchers into a collaborative environment
(MacEachren, 2000) where GIS are structured
under the guidance of both the expert and the
novice. One intended result is GIS appropriate
to the needs and uses of a given community,
with specific attention to the cultural
underpinnings of that community (Poore,
2003) and a raised level of empowerment for
the community taking part (Tulloch, 2007).
PPGIS from GISci shares a strong
resemblance to domain-analysis from IO in
that both contextualize the users‟ settings,
language, and culture as well as the goals
stated by the community in the process of
understanding that community. Where PPGIS
is unique is in the very purposeful use of GIS
technology in the collaborative action
research environment. Domain-analysis, on
the other hand, does not presuppose a
particular technological tool in support of the
process. In domain-analysis, the process of
devising an organization scheme could
produce a low-tech solution such as a file
cabinet if that meshed with the culture and
context better. So, domain-analysis and
PPGIS share similar inputs but the outputs
are defined differently.
The PPGIS construct is one logical method
for consciously attending to the unique
features of a given context. PPGIS methods
encourage both the practitioners and those
affected by a humanitarian situation to partner
together in assessing a situation, gathering
information, devising possible solutions, and
deciding on a plan together. PPGIS is
applicable to HA because the people most
affected by the humanitarian need are in the
centre of the process in a decision-making
role rather than standing on the outside in an
observer role.
Another possible GISci tool which can be
applied in HA contexts is a multi-user, multi-
modal GIS (Rauschert et al., 2002). Such a
tool set is a combination of inputs from a
computer mouse, touch screen, pen device,
or track ball alongside a large screen. The
large screen and multiple input devices permit
several users to work jointly in observing and
analyzing GI. Incorporating this technology
into PPGIS methods holds promise for HA
because the practitioners, both non-experts
and expert GIS analysts, and beneficiaries
can access and manipulate GI together,
keeping the human side of the context in
sight. Of course PPGIS, especially with a tool
as described in this paragraph, requires
100 Randall B. Kemp
CC: Creative Commons License, 2008.
infrastructure investment. Other less
technology-dependent methods do exist.
3.4. Example Project
Now that terms, background information,
and the potential tools have been outlined
above, a descriptive example of how the
many options might be collected into a formal
PPGIS project is in order. As mentioned
previously, this is not a prescriptive recipe, but
rather a descriptive possibility. I focus on the
use of GIS in the project.
Activity One – A Paper-Based, Memory-
Derived Map of the Local Watershed: In this
first step towards leveraging the strengths of
GIS, the researcher will gather the community
group (described above in the introductory
section) and ask each member to individually
graphically represent their local watershed.
The outcome for each may be a drawing on
paper showing boundaries, landmarks,
waterways, and the built environment. Others
may choose to narrate instead of draw their
perception of the watershed. Still others may
draw the map using more organic materials
such as plant materials to represent the
watershed.
As a group, then, we will attempt to
combine the various interpretations of the
geography into a single representation on a
large piece of paper. We will negotiate
understandings of the space and boundaries
through stories, legal definitions, and informal
agreements of property rights. The outcome
for Activity One will be a rudimentary map of
the watershed based on community input.
Activity Two – Ground-truthing the
Community Map: Taking the map in hand, the
community group will then walk the watershed
to verify the accuracy of the map. We will do
so with the aid of a GPS as a means to
precisely note the location of landmarks,
boundaries, water features, and the built
environment (such as homes, roads, dams,
planting fields, etc.).
After collecting as many data points with
the GPS as possible, the group will then begin
the comparison of the original map to the map
generated from the ground-truthing exercise.
The group will see where correlations and
discrepancies exist between the two maps
and have opportunity to explore the reasons
for both.
The GPS allows the precise notations of
location of features, which may differ from
memory. The GPS is a fairly unobtrusive
device comparable in size to a large mobile
phone. Even so, the unit will be explained to
the group so everyone understands what it is
and what it does.
Activity Three – Collaborative Spatial
Decision Making: The formal examination of
the outputs from Activity One and Activity Two
will take the form of a computer-based
exercise with a fully-functional GIS, large
computer monitors, and multiple human-
operated input devices. The devices could
include a normal mouse, a pen input device
for marking/drawing on a computer screen, or
even a large touch screen.
The original map will be displayed to the
group alongside the map generated from the
ground-truthing. The two maps will then be
overlaid on each other to visually show to all
users where overlaps and discrepancies exist.
The original paper-based map will first be
transformed into a digital representation.
With the large screens and input devices,
the group can then redraw boundaries or
highlight locations of other landmarks missed
in Activity One or Activity Two. Additionally,
layering ground cover, water features, roads,
buildings, temperature zones, and locations of
natural hazards on both maps can indicate
where human activities might need to be
altered, the existence of sites susceptible to
hazards, and hazard-free sites.
The community can then ask questions of
the data using the layers of data. For landslide
hazards: slope angles, soil composition, and
land cover. For flooding: water runoff, stream
locations, and flood plains. And so on for
other types of hazards.
4. Conclusions
As this research project is a work-in-
progress, I cannot report on findings from the
field as of yet. I hope to articulate findings
from the research activities which provide
clear evidence that the use of ICTs in disaster
risk reduction efforts are a key contributor to
improved information gathering, organization,
access, and use. GIS, in their extreme
tripleC 6(2): 88-104, 2008 101
CC: Creative Commons License, 2008.
application are sophisticated and a challenge
to manipulate. I hope to conclude that a
moderate implementation of GIS (more than
simply making pretty maps but also
geographic analysis) in the DRR project gives
the community new knowledge upon which
they can make decisions about reducing the
negative impacts of natural hazards.
5. Future Research
Additional questions, if the preliminary ones
I am asking now bear fruit, include issues of
wide-spread access to geographic information
through ICTs, long-term use of ICTs in DRR
efforts without an expert present, how formal
training of local participants in ICT use might
take place so that the participants might then
train others, and who are the community
members left out of the information sharing
dialog.
Further research might also include the use
of emerging geographic information
technologies not necessarily part of the
pantheon of GIS and tools. These might
include a GPS-enhanced mobile phone, a
location-aware handheld device, open source
GIS in a local telecenter, or the dispersal of
smart-clusters of miniature devices set to
passively gather environmental data then
transmit it back to a central source. The
environments of those regions most impacted
my natural hazards is wide open for exploring
and creativity in the gathering and organizing
of geographic information. ICTs are one way
to leverage the power of information in order
to reduce risk and the research questions
associated with this effort are many.
References
Aggett, G. & McColl, C. (2006). Evaluating decision support systems for PPGIS applications. Cartography and Geographic
Information Science, 33(1), 77-92.
Ahlqvist, O. & Keukelaar, J. & Oukbir, K. (2003). Rough and fuzzy geographical data integration. International Journal of
Geographical Information Science, 17(3), 223-234.
Albrechtsen, H. & Jacob, E. K. (1998). The dynamics of classification systems as boundary objects for cooperation in the
electronic library. Library Trends, 47(2), 293-312.
Alexander, D. (2002). Principles of emergency planning and management. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Barabási, A.-L. (2002). Linked: The new science of networks. Cambridge, MA: Perseus.
Bates, M. J. (1999). The invisible substrate of information science. Journal of the American Society of Information Science,
50(12), 1043-1050.
Bates, M. J. (2005). Information and knowledge: An evolutionary framework for information science. Information Research,
10(4), paper 239. Retrieved December 05, 2008, from http://InformationR.net/ir/10-4/paper239.html
Bates, M. J. (2006). Fundamental forms of information. Journal of the American Society of Information Science &
Technology, 57(8), 1033-1045.
Beghtol, C. (2004). Naïve classification systems and the global information society. In C. McIlwaine (Ed.), Proceedings of
the Seventh International ISKO Conference, volume 9, London, 2004 (pp. 19–22). Würzburg: Ergon.
Benini, A. A. (1997). Uncertainty and information flows in humanitarian agencies. Disasters, 21(4), 335-353.
Borko, H. (1968). Information science: What is it? American Documentation, 19(1), 3-5.
Bosher, L. & Carrillo, P. & Dainty, A. & Glass, J. & Price, A. (2007). Realising a resilient and sustainable built environment:
Towards a strategic agenda for the United Kingdom. Disasters 31(3), 236-255.
Bowker, G. C. (1998). The kindness of strangers: Kinds and politics in classification systems. Library Trends, 47(2), 255-
292.
Bowker, G. C. & S. L. Star (1999). Sorting things out: Classification and its consequences. Cambridge: MA: MIT Press.
Brown, L. D. & Bammer, G. & Batilwala, S. & Kunreuther, F. (2003). Framing practice-research engagement for
democratizing knowledge. Action Research 1(1), 81-102.
Buckland, M. (1991). Information as thing. Journal of the American Society for Information Science, 42(5), 351-360.
Buckland, M. (1999). The landscape of information science: The American Society for Information Science at 62. Journal of
the American Society for Information Science, 50(11), 970-974.
Burrough, P. A. & Frank, A. U. (1995). Concepts and paradigms in spatial information: Are current geographical information
systems truly generic? International Journal of Geographical Information Systems, 9(2), 101-116.
Chua, A. Y. K. & Kaynak, S. & Foo, S. S. B. (2007). An analysis of the delayed response to Hurricane Katrina through the
lens of knowledge management. Journal of the American Society of Information Science & Technology, 58(3), 391-
403.
102 Randall B. Kemp
CC: Creative Commons License, 2008.
Cooke, B. & Kothari, U. (Eds.) (2001). Participation: The new tyranny? London: Zed Books.
Crisp, J. (2003, September). Why do we know so little about refugees? How can we learn more? Forced Migration Review,
18, 55.
Dahlberg, I. (2006). Knowledge organization: A new science? Knowledge Organization 33(1), 11-19.
DFID Department for International Development (2005). Disaster risk reduction: A development concern. Retrieved
December 5, 2008, from http://www.dfid.gov.uk/Pubs/files/disaster-risk-reduction.pdf
Duckham, M. & Goodchild, M. F. & Worboys, M. F. (Eds.) (2003). Foundations of geographic information science. London:
Taylor & Francis.
Egenhofer, M. J. & Freksa, C. & Miller, H. J. (Eds.) (2004). Geographic Information Science, Lecture Notes in Computer
Science; 3234, Adelphi, MD. Berlin: Springer.
Egenhofer, M. J. & Mark, D. M. (1995). Naïve geography. In A. U. Frank & W. Kuhn (Eds.), Spatial information theory: A
theoretical basis for GIS : COSIT ‟95, Lecture notes in computer science; Austria (pp. 1-15). Berlin: Springer.
Eversole, R. (2003). Managing the pitfalls of participatory development: Some insight from Australia. World Development,
31(5), 781-795.
Floridi, L. (2004). Outline of a theory of strongly semantic information. Minds and Machines, 14, 197-221.
Floridi, L. (2005, March). Is semantic information meaningful data? Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, 70(2),
351-370.
Freudenberger, K. (1999). Rapid Rural Response Appraisal & Participatory Rural Appraisal (RRA/PRA). CRS publication.
Retrieved June 2, 2008, from http://crs.org/publications/pdf/Gen1199_e.pdf
Goodchild, M. F. (1992). Geographical information science. International Journal of Geographical Information Systems, 6(1),
31-45.
Goodchild, M. F. (2000). Communicating geographic information in a digital age. Annals of the Association of American
Geographers, 90(2), 344-355.
Goodchild, M. F. (2001). A geographer looks at spatial information theory. In D. R. Montello (Ed.), COSIT, Lecture notes in
computer science; 2205, Morro Bay, CA (pp. 1–13). Berlin: Springer.
Goodchild, M. F. (2003). Geographic information science and systems for environmental management. Annual Review of
Environmental Resources, 28, 493-519.
Goodchild, M. F. & Anselin, L. & Appelbaum, R. P. & Harthorn, B. H. (2000). Toward spatially integrated social science.
International Regional Science Review, 23(2), 139-159.
Goodchild, M. F. & Egenhofer, M. J. & Kemp, K. K. & Mark, D. M. & Sheppard, E. (1999). Introduction to the Varenius
project. International Journal of Geographical Information Science, 13(8), 731-745.
Granger, K. (2000). An information infrastructure for disaster management in Pacific island countries. Australian Journal of
Emergency Management, 15(1), 20-32.
Gray, M. V. (1997). Classification as in impediment to the reliable and valid use of spatial information: A disaggregate
approach. In S. C. Hirtle & A. U. Frank (Eds.), COSIT 97: Spatial information theory: A theoretical basis for GIS,
Lecture Notes in Computer Science; 1329, Laurel Highlands, PA, (pp. 137-149). Berlin: Springer.
Harvey, F. & Chrisman, N. (1998). Boundary objects and the social construction of GIS technology. Environment and
Planning, A 30, 1683-1694.
Hjørland, B. (2002). The methodology of constructing classification schemes: A discussion of the state-of-the-art. In M. J.
López-Huertas (Ed.), Proceedings of the Seventh International ISKO Conference, volume 8, Granada, Spain (pp.
450-456). Würzburg: Ergon.
Hjørland, B. (2003). Fundamentals of knowledge organization. Knowledge Organization, 30(2), 87-111.
Houser, L. (1988). A conceptual analysis of information science. Library and Information Science, 10, 3-34.
Howcroft, D. & Wilson, M. (2003). Paradoxes of participatory practices: The Janus role of the systems developer.
Information and Organization, 13, 1-24.
HPN (2007, June). Disaster risk reduction. Humanitarian Exchange, 38, 1-32.
IFRC (2005). World disasters report 2005: Focus on information in disasters. Bloomfield: Kumarian Press.
Introna, L. D. (2002). The (im)possibility of ethics in the information age. Information and Organization, 12, 71-84.
ISDR (2007). Words into action: A guide for implementing the Hyogo framework. Retrieved December 5, 2008, from
http://www.unisdr.org/eng/about_isdr/isdr-publications/02-words-into-action/words-into-action.pdf
Jayatilaka, D. & Muggah, R. (2004, May). Where there is no information: IDP vulnerability assessments in Sri Lanka‟s
borderlands. Forced Migration Review, 20, 39-41.
Lakoff, G. (1987). Women, fire, and dangerous things: What categories reveal about the mind. Chicago: University of
Chicago Press.
Lindenberg, M. & Bryant, C. (2001). Going global: Transforming relief and development NGOs. Bloomfield: Kumarian Press.
López-Huertas, M. J. (Ed.) (2002). Proceedings of the Seventh International ISKO Conference, Volume 8, Granada, Spain.
Würzburg: Ergon.
tripleC 6(2): 88-104, 2008 103
CC: Creative Commons License, 2008.
Losee, R. M. (1997). A discipline independent definition of information. Journal of the American Society of Information
Science, 48(3), 254-269.
MacEachren, A. M. (2000). Cartography and GIS: Facilitating collaboration. Progress in Human Geography, 24(3), 445-456.
MacKay, D. M. (1953). Quantal aspects of scientific information. IEEE Transactions on Information Theory, 1(1), 60-80.
Mai, J.-E. (2002). Is classification theory possible? Rethinking classification research. In , M. J. López-Huertas (Ed.),
Proceedings of the Seventh International ISKO Conference, Volume 8, Granada, Spain (pp. 472–478). Würzburg:
Ergon.
Mai, J.-E. (2004a). Classification in context: Relativity, reality, and representation. Knowledge Organization, 31(1), 39-48.
Mai, J.-E. (2004b). The role of documents, domains and decisions in indexing. In I. C. McIlwaine (Ed.), Proceedings of the
Seventh International ISKO Conference, Volume 9, London (pp. 207–213). Würzburg: Ergon.
Manyena, S. B. (2006). The concept of resilience revisited. Disasters, 30(4), 433-450.
Mark, D. M. & Freksa, C. & Hirtle, S. C. & Lloyd, R. & Tversky, B. (1999). Cognitive models of geographical space.
International Journal of Geographical Information Science, 13(8), 747-774.
McIlwaine, I. C. (Ed.) (2004). Proceedings of the Seventh International ISKO Conference, Volume 9, London. Würzburg:
Ergon.
McKinnon, K. (2007). Postdevelopment, professionalism, and the politics of participation. Annals of the Association of
American Geographers, 97(4), 772-785.
McPhee, J. A. (1989). The control of nature. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
Miller, H. J. (2003). What about people in geographic information science. Computers, Environment and Urban Systems, 27,
447-453.
Montello, D. R. (Ed.) (2001). COSIT, Lecture notes in computer science; 2205, Morro Bay, CA. Berlin: Springer.
Norton, M. J. (2000). Introductory concepts in information science. Medford, NJ: ASIS.
Nyerges, T. & Jankowski, P. & Drew, C. (2002). Data-gathering strategies for social-behavioural research about
participatory geographical information system use. International Journal of Geographical Information Science ,16(1),
1-22.
O‟Brien, G. & O‟Keefe, P. & Rose, J. & Wisner, B. (2006). Climate change and disaster management. Disasters, 30(1), 64-
80.
Olson, H. A. (1998). Mapping beyond Dewey‟s boundaries: constructing classificatory space for marginalized knowledge
domains. Library Trends, 47(2), 233-254.
Olson, H. A. (2001). The power to name: Representation in library catalogs. Signs, 26(3), 639-668.
Olson, H. A. & Schlegl, R. (2001). Standardization, objectivity, and user focus: A meta-analysis of subject access critiques.
Cataloging & Classification Quarterly, 32(2), 61-80.
O‟Reilly, K. (2004). Developing contradictions: Women‟s participation as a site of struggle wihtin an Indian NGO.
Professional Geographer, 56(2), 174-184.
Ottosson, S. (2003). Participation action research: A key to improved knowledge of management. Technovation, 23, 87-94.
Pelling, M. (2007). Learning from others: The scope and challenges for participatory disaster risk assessment. Disasters,
31(4), 373-385.
Poore, B. S. (2003). The open black box: The role of the end-user in GIS integration. Canadian Geographer, 47(1), 62-74.
Powell, M. (2003). Information management for development organizations (2. ed.). Oxford: Oxfam GB.
Raper, J. & Dykes, J. & Wood, J. & Mountain, D. & Krause, A. & Rhind, D. (2002). A framework for evaluating geographical
information. Journal of Information Science, 28(1), 39-50.
Rauschert, I. & Agrawal, P. & Sharma, R. & Fuhrmann, S. & Brewer, I. & MacEachren, A. (2002). Designing a human-
centered, multimodal GIS interface to support emergency management. In GIS ’02: Proceedings of the 10th ACM
international symposium on Advances in geographic information systems (pp. 119–124). New York: ACM Press.
Rodgers, G. (2004, September). „Hanging out‟ with forced migrants: Methodological and ethical challenges. Forced
Migration Review, 21, 48-49.
Saracevic, T. (1992). Information science: Origin, evolution and relations. In P. Vakkari (Ed.), Conceptions of library and
information science: Historical, empirical, and theoretical perspectives (pp. 5-27). London: Taylor Graham.
Schipper, L. & Pelling, M. (2006). Disaster risk, climate change and international development: Scope for, and challenges
to, integration. Disasters, 30(1), 19-38.
Schrader, A. M. (1984). In search of a name: Information science and its conceptual antecedents. Library and Information
Science Research, 6, 227-271.
Sen, A. (1999). Development as freedom. New York: Anchor.
Sida, L. & Szpak, C. (2004, Aug). An evaluation of Humanitarian Information Centers: Including case studies of HICs for
Iraq, Afghanistan, and Liberia. Retrieved December 5, 2008, from http://www.reliefweb.int/rw/lib.nsf/db900sid/LHON-
67BCX3/$file/Evaluation_HIC_USAID_Aug_2004.pdf?openelement
Sieber, R. E. (2003). Public participation geographic information systems across borders. Canadian Geographer, 47(1), 50-
61.
104 Randall B. Kemp
CC: Creative Commons License, 2008.
Sieber, R. E. (2006). Public participation geographic information systems: A literature review and framework. Annals of the
Association of American Geographers, 96(3), 491-507.
Stephenson, Jr., M. (2005). Making humanitarian relief networks more effective: Operational coordination, trust and sense
making. Disasters, 29(4), 337-350.
Suchman, L. (1994). Do categories have politics? The language/action perspective reconsidered. Computer Supported
Cooperative Work, 2, 177-190.
Svenonius, E. (2001). The intellectual foundation of information organization. Cambridge: MIT Press.
Troy, D. A. & Carson, A. & Vanderbeek, J. & Hutton, A. (2007). Enhancing community-based disaster preparedness with
informatino technology. Disasters, 32(1), 149-165.
Tulloch, D. L. (2007, February). Many, many maps: Empowerment and online participatory mapping. First Monday, 12(2).
Retrieved December 5, 2008, from http://firstmonday.org/htbin/cgiwrap/bin/ojs/index.php/fm/article/view/1620
Uehling, G. (2004, May). How can we obtain the information we need about refugees? Forced Migration Review, 20, 48.
UNDP (2004). Reducing disaster risk: A challenge for development. Retrieved December 5, 2008, from
http://www.undp.org/cpr/whats_new/rdr_english.pdf
Vakkari, P. (Ed.) (1992). Conceptions of library and information science: Historical, empirical, and theoretical perspectives.
London: Taylor Graham.
van Aalst, M. K. (2006). The impacts of climate change on the risk of natural disasters. Disasters, 30(1), 5-18.
Walker, D. & Jones, III, J. P. & Roberts, S. M. & Fröhling, O. R. (2007). When participation meets empowerment: The WWF
and the politics of invitation in the Chimalapas, Mexico. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 97(2),
423-444.
Wamsler, C. (2006). Mainstreaming risk reduction in urban planning and housing: A challenge for international aid
organisations. Disasters, 30(2), 151-177.
Warschauer, M. (2004). Technology and social inclusion: Rethinking the digital divide. Cambridge: MIT Press.
Wilson, P. (1968). Two kinds of power: An essay on bibliographical control. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Worboys, M. F. (2003). Communicating geographic information in context. In M. Duckham & M. F. Goodchild & M. F.
Worboys (Eds.), Foundations of geographic information science (pp. 33-45). London: Taylor & Francis.
Wright, D. J. & Goodchild, M. F. & Proctor, J. D. (1997). GIS: Tool or science? Annals of the Association of American
Geographers, 87(2), 346-362.
Yates, J. (1989). Control through communication: The rise of system in American management. Baltimore: The Johns
Hopkins University Press.
Zins, C. (2006). Redefining information science: From “information science” to “knowledge science”. Journal of
Documentation, 62(4), 447-461.
About the Author
Randall B. Kemp
is PhD candidate at the Information School at the University of Washington (Seattle, Washington, USA).