
96 Randall B. Kemp
CC: Creative Commons License, 2008.
indexing (establishing the subject matter of an
object and assigning terms from, typically, a
controlled vocabulary, of documents). What
terms are assigned by the indexer will help or
hinder the users‟ access of that information. If
the indexer takes into consideration the
domain, the communication, essentially,
between the indexer and the user will be
clearer (Mai, 2004b).
The purpose and goal of an organizing
scheme belong in this discussion of context
and are highlighted as a particular aspect of
context because the end goal of a scheme
dramatically affects the design and
implementation of the scheme. It is also true
that classificatory schemes are political tools
because their creation, at least within the
context of an organized group of people,
carries an “agenda of discipline and control
over organization members‟ actions”
(Suchman, 1994, p. 178). If categorizing
people within an organization impose control
on a person‟s responsibility and freedom,
imposing bibliographic control over
documents, as another example, also implies
power over those information objects (Wilson,
1968, p. 6). Both Yates (1989) and the telling
case studies in McPhee (1989) explore
control: one the organizational, the other
nature itself. The purpose of an organizing
structure need not contain the potentially
insidious goal of power. Instead, certain
values, views, and biases subjectively
facilitate or hinder effectiveness of that
structure (Olson, 1998, 2001; Olson and
Schlegl, 2001; Svenonius, 2001; Hjørland,
2002, 2003).
Bowker (1998, p. 255) adroitly highlights
the “relationship between the use of the
classification as an information storage and
retrieval mechanism and its use to encode
multiple political and ethical agendas.” A
scheme cannot, however, classify every
possible bit of relevant information but must
make practical trade-offs (1998, p. 261)
because the system is developed within a
context of organizational practice (1998, p.
264). Additionally, the inflexibility of such
schemes reinforces the existing organization
of information because changes to the
scheme impact the usefulness of previously
organized information (1998, p. 268), even
though schemes might represent one period
in time (with the knowledge known and
recorded at that time) while the world has
changed (Bowker, 1998, p. 271). So, the
context is not only that of the intellectual
content of a given scheme but also the
people, place, and time (1998, p. 273).
Optimistically, the political nature (rigidity) of a
scheme allows the scientific community to
communicate, publish, research, and
otherwise conducts its work due in, at least a
small, part to the scheme at hand (1998, p.
284).
In the family of constructs subsumed under
the heading of context, the notion of a
universal classification scheme can now be
discussed in light of context and purpose of a
scheme. Since information organizing
schemes, to be effective, are contextualized
and created with a purpose, building a
scheme with universal applicability can be
successful only if success is defined as
attending to the lowest common denominator
and completely satisfying only a portion of
users (Mai, 2002, p. 477). The primary
emphasis of contextualization, then, is on
local classification schemes tied to specific
needs and goals of a defined community.
The users of a classification scheme are
considered an important contributor to framing
the context and purpose of the scheme. They
are, therefore, integrated into the design of
the scheme. Although the sentiment that “it is
important to involve the eventual users of the
[HA] information in the design and
development of the collection process”
(Granger, 2000, p. 21) is present in HA
discussions, participation of beneficiaries in
the processes of HA more often than not,
when they touch on information issues, center
on extraction of information from beneficiaries
over and above sharing information with
beneficiaries or incorporating them into the
information collection decisions. One reason
for this is that they are not viewed as users of
information but providers only (IFRC, 2005).
See Cooke and Kothari (2001); Brown et al.
(2003); Eversole (2003) for critical
perspectives – both positive and cautionary –
on participatory research in development. HA
can learn from the IO construct of valuing
local context by including users in the design
and implementation of information
organization schemes so that the scheme will