
The rapid and largely anarchic
development of information and
communication technologies and their
applications has stimulated many formulations
and definitions of an “Information Society” (IS)
from, especially, technological, political and
economic standpoints (Knowledge Politics,
2007). Theorizing about the IS and the related
concept of a “Knowledge-Based Economy”
(KBE) has focused on these aspects. An
ethics for the emerging IS has also been
proposed by collective work, especially at the
government level (World Summit on the
Information Society, 2005) which, however,
generally concentrates on bridging
inequalities in access to necessary
technological developments.
In a key Report (Hofkirchner, Fuchs, Raffl,
Schafranek, Sandoval, & Bichler, 2007), “ICTs
and Society” (below ICTs&S), Wolfgang
Hofkirchner, Christian Fuchs and their
colleagues at the University of Salzburg have
insisted that a new evolutionary theory “for,
about and by means of” the IS is necessary
and must be both descriptive and normative.
In other words, the major objective of the
theory is its ultimate use as a tool for
development of a moral, ecologically and
globally sustainable information society –
GSIS (Fuchs, 2006b).
The objective of this paper is to propose
that a new kind of logic, applicable to real
systems and phenomena, is the “missing
ingredient” required for a rigorous theory that
meets these requirements. I suggest that such
logic is the non-propositional, dialectic “Logic
in Reality” (LIR) that I have recently described
(Brenner, 2008a). In my opinion, this would be
an advance on currently available theoretical
foundations of a GSIS which use or refer to
theories of society, information and
economics in which the underlying logic is
essentially bivalent classical logic, a logic of
“exclusion”. Indeed, Barinaga and Ramfelt
(2004), quoting Castells, stated that one of the
challenges of the “network society” is that it’s
very logic is based on an idealized, one-sided
conception of society that excludes an
important part of the world population. In
contrast, Fuchs (2006a) suggests the need for
a new functional “logic of self-organization” in
another recent paper in this Journal.
Otherwise expert and comprehensive
analytical models of the KBE (Leydesdorff,
2006) fail to deal with normative aspects of
development, so that the “meaning” of the
meaning of information remains ambiguous,
without a moral dimension.
In this paper, I describe the essential
components of my “logic of and in reality”,
LIR, and show that it has the capability of
addressing and illuminating issues raised by
Hofkirchner et al. in their evolutionary
“Salzburg Approach”, as outlined in the
ICTs&S document. Starting from basic
principles, it founds a logical approach to a
theory of systems applicable to both groups
and individuals and their interaction, and to
the negative as well as the positive aspects of
current technological developments. It thus
supports efforts to disentangle ethical and
technological issues (Tavani, 2007). LIR
provides a new logical interpretation of key
concepts in social theory including morality,
self-organization, cooperation and conflict,
grounding them in physical reality and
authorizing logical inference. The term
“evolutionary” itself is discussed in terms of
similarities and differences with biological
evolution. LIR offers a logical explication and
expansion of Fuchs’ statement that nature
and society are both identical and non-
identical.
The Logic of and in Reality proposed in this
paper (LIR) permits new descriptions of the
underlying reality that current theories of the
individual and society purport to describe, as
well as the structure of the theories
themselves. It is hoped that the interpretations
provided may serve as templates for the
ordering by specialists in the various fields
and sub-fields of both theoretical and
practical, action-oriented approaches to
societal issues. Because this logical system is
grounded in and reflects the dualistic structure
of fundamental physical reality, it incorporates
a degree of transdisciplinary generality that
may 1) simplify certain problems by resolving
stalled debates about opposing concepts; and
2) provide in addition, through a more general
and “public”, non-sectarian concept of the
origin of morality, scientific support for an
appropriate ethics for the IS; and 3) authorize
the inclusion of concepts from both scientific
and non-scientific disciplines in a
transdisciplinary approach to a unity of