
Fe school on self-organized criticality. We
have also seen that this kind of discussion
visualizes processes in the general sense as
percolation phenomena
26
, and what is being
percolated is information then. And we have
seen that it is topos theory that provides an
appropriate language in order to deal with
these aspects of spatial representation. More
than that: A topos can be essentially
interpreted as the algebraic expression of the
fact that spaces utilized in human cognition
are basically constituted by propositions of
logical theories. On the other hand, the
procedures of deduction and induction as well
as creative abduction, available to human
logic, can be rephrased in terms of algorithmic
procedures. Hence, they are both accessible
by means of programmes as they are utilized
in computation, and by means of game
theory, because on a fundamental level of
reflexion games are essentially algorithmic
procedures whose strategies are given by its
rules.
27
What we realize then is that all of this
relates nicely with the approaches of the
Kassel and Salzburg schools as described at
earlier occasions.
28
Note that the conceptual nucleus of these
approaches is given by two triadic
arrangements of concepts of the form:
Cognition Communication
Co-
operation
Space Network System
The first triadic structure mirrors the close
relationship between cognition and
26
Cf. Dietrich Stauffer, Amnon Aharony: Introduction
to Percolation Theory. Taylor & Francis, London, 2
nd
ed.,
1994.
27
Cf. Robin Houston: Categories of Games. Master
thesis, University of Manchester, 2003.
28
Cf. the volumes of collected essays presenting the
results of the INTAS co-operation project “Human
Systems in Transition” with the universities of Vienna,
Kassel, Kyiv, and the Academy of Sciences, Moscow led
by Wolfgang Hofkirchner (then Vienna, now Salzburg),
namely by V. Arshinov, C. Fuchs (eds.): Causality,
Emergence, Self-Organization (Volume 1), Russian
Academy of Science, NIA-Priroda, Moscow, 2003. Also I.
Dobronravova, W. Hofkirchner (eds.): Science of Self-
Organization and Self-Organization of Science (Volume
2), Abris, Kyiv, 2004. And R. E. Zimmermann, V. Budanov
(eds.): Towards Otherland. Languages of Science and
Languages Beyond. Kassel University Press, 2005.
communication on the one hand – as pair of
concepts characterizing the process of
reflexion – and co-operation on the other hand
– as characterizing the transition from
reflexion to action.
29
While the first pair of
concepts cannot be separated in practise, the
latter concept is structurally separable from
the other two. Reflexion and action represent
thus two different time scales which show up
with the systematic updating process involved
in the sequential organization which is
underlying both reflexion and action,
respectively. The producing of models
belongs to the pair of concepts in the first
place and is primarily based on a generic self-
model which defines the framework according
to which cognition is normalized. Essentially,
this is the onto-epistemic picture of the
grasping of the world by humans.
30
Earlier
stages of evolution can be visualized as
conceptual approximations of this onto-
epistemic picture. In methodological terms the
second triadic structure is associated with the
first such that there are intrinsic pairwise
correspondences between cognition and
space, communication and network, and co-
operation and system, respectively. In other
words: Space is the conceptual structure from
which that world of daily life is being
reconstructed which is derived from the
process of cognition. Network is the
29
See for more details Rainer E. Zimmermann:
Konzeptuelle Dialektik (Conference of the Ernst Bloch
association on Polyphonic Dialectics, Berlin, 2007), in:
Doris Zeilinger (ed.), VorSchein, Nuernberg, in press.
(2008)
30
In other words: It is the human mode of being to
produce knowledge. Hence, for humans, ontology and
epistemology fall into one. Higher and lower animals, in
principle also plants, represent the same scheme, but on
lower levels of organization. Essentially, even physical
systems on a very fundamental level can be thought of as
satisfying the general framework of this scheme, though
by extremely simple means of organization. In the sense
of Stuart Kauffman, the most fundamental physical
(autonomous) agent can be defined by satisfying a
minimal condition from thermodynamics: namely that the
system is able to perform at least one thermodynamic
work cycle. This is probably true for spin networks on the
level of quantized physical space. Hence, evolution
shows up as a multi-shifted hierarchy of complexity as to
the unfolding of various forms of organized collectives of
(autonomous) agents. Humans represent thus systems
with (up to now) maximal degree of organization. In
between we would expect a manifold of biological
structures with different degrees of organization smaller
than that degree in humans.