29 Rui H. Dos Santos Martin
CC: Creative Commons License, 2010.
Descartes, Galileo, Newton and Mersenne
(Shapin, 2008).
Although in many respects we have moved
far away from the Newtonian method of
solving problems, our professions remain
focused on the search for certainty. This is
underpinned by the mechanistic and deter-
ministic modern scientific method and episte-
mology in the name of material progress and
for the betterment of humanity. Through re-
ductionist research, individual professions, as
various authors have suggested (Berman,
1981, Kuhn et al., 2000, Shapin, 1996), still
frame problems at a distance from the object
of inquiry and its highly selected bounded
context. This implies that we as a culture in
the West still exist in varying degrees under
the epistemological grip of the mechanistic
paradigm.
The fundamental axiom of modern profes-
sions is based on prediction and control,
which is a view held by critical theorists such
as Adorno, Horkheimer, Habermas and
Weber (Leiss, 1994). Furthermore, profes-
sional knowledge, as suggested by Foucault
(1980), is a contest for power, since it is
power, rather than fact about reality, that
makes things true. This results in the em-
powerment of experts and the exclusion of the
community. Humans and their relationship to
the environment (context/structure) are the
object of study. Professional objectivity, rea-
soning, model building and empirical testing
focus on efficiency and technological advan-
ces as the underpinning of development and
progress, in which the ‘subject’ is a passive
element in the act of cognition (Castro-
Gomez, 2001). This results in a reality that is
fragmented.
The mechanistic paradigm approaches
problems from a closed systems’ perspective,
where the life of the ‘structure’ is considered,
while disregarding the subject, reducing prob-
lems to ‘technical’ and removing the barriers
for the growth of capital and the maximization
of profit (Castro-Gomez, 2001).
The challenges to the mechanistic model
are numerous. One of these challenges was
launched by the ecological movement at the
end of the 1960s as a values-driven social
movement (Goldsmith, 1988) to redress the
dualistic disconnect between humans and
nature as separate entities. The Aristotelian
teleological holistic worldview served as a
cultural constraint, restraining human activity
in respect of the environment. This mutual
interdependency was lost with the anti-
animistic opposition of the dualistic view of
creation and reality, where nature was to be
‘used’ at the service and ‘progress’ of hu-
manity (Henry, 2008). The environmental
movement has increasingly taken ‘centre
stage’, questioning old assumptions about
who we are, how we interact with each other,
and the ethical conduct of professions vis-à-
vis the community/environment, including our
political and economic structures (Merchant,
2005).
More recently, the concern for global warm-
ing, exemplified by the sustainability debate,
has rearranged the dynamics of humans from
being at the top of the pyramid to the envi-
ronment as an overarching circle that contains
human society and in turn the economy
(Mitchell, 2000). Further allies in support of
this emerging paradigm are:
The ‘deep ecology’ philosophy (Naess,
1973) of ‘being’, where beings cannot be
ranked by their relative value, which together
with all species become “aspects of a single
unfolding order” (Fox, 1990, p252);
The general systems theory (developed in
the first half of the 20
th
century) reinforces the
view that various systems maintain and trans-
form themselves as dissipative structures far-
from-equilibrium, viewing the universe as an
organised complexity of systems intercon-
nected and interacting (Laszlo, 1987,
Prigogine et al., 1984);
Over the last decade, this concept has
been further reinforced with the Gaia hypoth-
esis (Lovelock, 2000), where the biosphere
and other components of the Earth are closely
integrated to form a complex interacting sys-
tem, viewed as a single organism. This theory
(no longer considered as an hypothesis since
it has passed predictive tests) reinforced the
urgency with which we, as a society, need to
redress the expansionist world view, in par-
ticular global warming. The health of Gaia
together with life on this planet is at great risk.