tripleC 8(1): pp 28-35, 2010
ISSN 1726-670X
http://www.triple-c.at
CC: Creative Commons License, 2010.
Reflection (Non Peer-Reviewed)
Sustainable Development Requires an Integrated Design
Discipline to Address Unique Problems
Rui H. Dos Santos Martins
143 Donnelly Rd, Arcadia Vale NSW, Australia
rui@dsmartins.com
Abstra ct: Sustainable development has taken centre stage in our global conscience. Until recently, we have been focused
on economic prosperity, driven by the mechanistic worldview of the scientific method. Once the cracks appeared, as a
society, we have been looking for a deeper meaning and approach to life. Through a literature review, the paper proposes
that current ‘experts’, using the engineering profession as an example, are not able to address the wicked problems con-
fronting us, since they prevail within the reductionist mode of knowledge production. We need design thinkers - who are
natural systemic practitioners -to solve systemic problems, which is characterised by sustainable development.
A future second paper will draw on the behavior of non-linear, complex adaptive systems as self-organizing emergence at
the edge of chaos and re-interpret the design thinking process in a way which encompasses the intuitive, non-linear and
qualitative way in which sustainable development problems need to be addressed.
Keywords: design thinking; sustainable development; systems thinking.
1. Introduction
Until recently, our global society has fo-
cused mainly on economic development. ‘Pro-
fessional practice’ has assisted in this en-
deavour by delivering products and services
so that entrepreneurs and business in general
is able to achieve this single objective. At the
same time, there is an awareness that more
problems were often being created at another
level, treating business as separate from the
environment.
Professionals/experts are trained to solve
the problem given to them by their ‘client’. If
an issue is not defined by the brief then it is
not to be addressed – ‘it is out of scope!’
There are endless examples where various
professional groups are on record as having
created more problems in the process of
solving another problem. Simplification only
examines issues at a superficial level and
specialisation examines a square inch of de-
tail of the whole picture - both therefore only
examine limited aspects of the issues at hand.
We need a new perspective to see reality
differently (Martin, 2007). Design Thinking
promises to do this.
Sustainable development is not a new con-
cept. Yet we are now increasingly aware as a
society of the implications and possible con-
sequences of any form of development that is
not sustainable. This implies a serious decon-
struction and reconfiguration of many aspects
of our lives, in particular, how can experts
ensure that they are responsibly delivering
sustainable solutions to the community, the
market and society?
The objective of this paper is to outline the
proposition that ʻdesign thinkingʼ, as a sys-
temic process, is an essential discipline that is
able to solve complex and messy problems
such as sustainable development.
2. Historical Context
The history of professional development is
a complex story. Through a combination of
socio-political, economic, religious and cul-
tural forces (Seitz, 1992), a science emerged
that emphasised a mechanistic attitude to
nature and whose advocates included Bacon,
29 Rui H. Dos Santos Martin
CC: Creative Commons License, 2010.
Descartes, Galileo, Newton and Mersenne
(Shapin, 2008).
Although in many respects we have moved
far away from the Newtonian method of
solving problems, our professions remain
focused on the search for certainty. This is
underpinned by the mechanistic and deter-
ministic modern scientific method and episte-
mology in the name of material progress and
for the betterment of humanity. Through re-
ductionist research, individual professions, as
various authors have suggested (Berman,
1981, Kuhn et al., 2000, Shapin, 1996), still
frame problems at a distance from the object
of inquiry and its highly selected bounded
context. This implies that we as a culture in
the West still exist in varying degrees under
the epistemological grip of the mechanistic
paradigm.
The fundamental axiom of modern profes-
sions is based on prediction and control,
which is a view held by critical theorists such
as Adorno, Horkheimer, Habermas and
Weber (Leiss, 1994). Furthermore, profes-
sional knowledge, as suggested by Foucault
(1980), is a contest for power, since it is
power, rather than fact about reality, that
makes things true. This results in the em-
powerment of experts and the exclusion of the
community. Humans and their relationship to
the environment (context/structure) are the
object of study. Professional objectivity, rea-
soning, model building and empirical testing
focus on efficiency and technological advan-
ces as the underpinning of development and
progress, in which the ‘subject’ is a passive
element in the act of cognition (Castro-
Gomez, 2001). This results in a reality that is
fragmented.
The mechanistic paradigm approaches
problems from a closed systems’ perspective,
where the life of the ‘structure’ is considered,
while disregarding the subject, reducing prob-
lems to ‘technical’ and removing the barriers
for the growth of capital and the maximization
of profit (Castro-Gomez, 2001).
The challenges to the mechanistic model
are numerous. One of these challenges was
launched by the ecological movement at the
end of the 1960s as a values-driven social
movement (Goldsmith, 1988) to redress the
dualistic disconnect between humans and
nature as separate entities. The Aristotelian
teleological holistic worldview served as a
cultural constraint, restraining human activity
in respect of the environment. This mutual
interdependency was lost with the anti-
animistic opposition of the dualistic view of
creation and reality, where nature was to be
‘used’ at the service and ‘progress’ of hu-
manity (Henry, 2008). The environmental
movement has increasingly taken ‘centre
stage’, questioning old assumptions about
who we are, how we interact with each other,
and the ethical conduct of professions vis-à-
vis the community/environment, including our
political and economic structures (Merchant,
2005).
More recently, the concern for global warm-
ing, exemplified by the sustainability debate,
has rearranged the dynamics of humans from
being at the top of the pyramid to the envi-
ronment as an overarching circle that contains
human society and in turn the economy
(Mitchell, 2000). Further allies in support of
this emerging paradigm are:
The ‘deep ecology’ philosophy (Naess,
1973) of ‘being’, where beings cannot be
ranked by their relative value, which together
with all species become “aspects of a single
unfolding order” (Fox, 1990, p252);
The general systems theory (developed in
the first half of the 20
th
century) reinforces the
view that various systems maintain and trans-
form themselves as dissipative structures far-
from-equilibrium, viewing the universe as an
organised complexity of systems intercon-
nected and interacting (Laszlo, 1987,
Prigogine et al., 1984);
Over the last decade, this concept has
been further reinforced with the Gaia hypoth-
esis (Lovelock, 2000), where the biosphere
and other components of the Earth are closely
integrated to form a complex interacting sys-
tem, viewed as a single organism. This theory
(no longer considered as an hypothesis since
it has passed predictive tests) reinforced the
urgency with which we, as a society, need to
redress the expansionist world view, in par-
ticular global warming. The health of Gaia
together with life on this planet is at great risk.
tripleC 8(1): 28-35, 2010 30
CC: Creative Commons License, 2010.
2.1. Sustainability Clarified
Before exploring the proposition further, a
brief look at what is understood by the term
sustainability is necessary.
Although widely used, the term “sustaina-
bility” remains difficult to define. Dobson
(1996) found over 300 different definitions.
This could, however, be a good thing, as sug-
gested by Jacobs (1999), where a single uni-
versal definition would be counter productive.
The best thing one can do is address this
ambiguity within the specific context.
For the purpose of this paper, the following
sustainability criteria are considered important
or at least relevant:
• It is a systemic concept;
• It is concerned with the continuity of en-
vironmental, social, economic and insti-
tutional aspects of human activity;
• It is concerned with the non-human envi-
ronment;
• It looks at the means by which present
and future needs are met whilst preser-
ving biodiversity and natural ecosystems;
• It focuses on a good quality of life for all
humans; and
• All levels of society, from the neighbour-
hood to the entire planet are concerned
and affected.
Recognizing that each community has
unique aspirations, as do individuals, the ‘one-
size fits all’ approach would not be recom-
mended as a way forward. What needs to be
recognized is that, as a global society, we
appear to agree that current practice is not
acceptable and that achieving sustainable
solutions call for stewardship by the entire
environment.
The critical point is that the way of thinking
that brought us to the situation we are in now
needs to change. Business cannot carry on as
usual. We would be fooling ourselves to think
that all we need to do is simply adjust current
practice.
2.1.1. Sustainability Requires A New Way
Of Thinking
The aim of this paper is to explore an ap-
proach to solve problems in an environment
that has shifted from the expansionist mode of
production to one of co-existence with the
environment. The solution points to design
thinking.
To summarise our argument so far - there
are numerous converging strands:
• We are in an economic crisis that appears
to be changing the relationship between
business and society. Reforming the econ-
omy might not have traction because peo-
ple are looking for alternatives. Sustaina-
bility will have great influence in the recon-
figuration as people lose faith with current
formal structures of power and control and
the future is complex, fragmented and fluid
(Robertson, 1983);
• Quantum theory – describes probabilistic
reality, rejection of fundamentalist and posi-
tivist notions of knowledge to complemen-
tary modes of knowledge. The implications
for this are that the world is not necessarily
sensible and predictable, where specialists
need to embrace the notion of both/and,
where certainty and truth are relative and
reconstructed actions. Wheeler refers to
this as the ‘participatory universe’ (Bohm et
al., 1993);
• Deep Ecology – has been used to criticize
modern society and, until recently, was re-
garded as part of the ‘far left’. However, it
has now reached a tipping point where
people find legitimacy within main stream
society to explore and realize their spiritual,
aesthetic, ethical, moral needs and con-
cerns, through its notion of wholeness and
essence of ‘being’ (Fry, 2006);
• Sustainable development – as suggested
by Walker (2006, p 15), is a “mythic story
that attempts to give meaning to some of
our principle modern-day uncertainties”,
mainly “as a socially acceptable, contempo-
rary means of framing our enduring ethical
dilemmas and moral choices, as well as our
ideas of social justice and environmental
stewardship” (p26).
The mechanistic paradigm placed humans
at the apex of the universe. This was about
creating a new way to generate knowledge
(the scientific method) with the objective of
improving the human condition. As a society,
31 Rui H. Dos Santos Martin
CC: Creative Commons License, 2010.
we have been operating under this paradigm
for over 350 years. We are now coming to the
conclusion that this paradigm, although suc-
cessful, has destroyed its own foundations
(Sagasti, 1990) through the destruction of the
environment, bringing us to the realisation that
we need to reconsider our links with nature
and our dualistic understanding of body and
soul.
Paradigms are human constructs. We cre-
ate them to make sense of the world and to
be able to act within it. They are not true in
themselves. Theories are necessary for us as
a community to collectively organise know-
ledge, stimulate debate and test.
The reductionist method started to show
some ‘cracks’ when issues and phenomena
could not be explained by the methodology.
The new set of perspectives, from quantum
physics, systems, complexity, chaos to cos-
mology have led us to create new understand-
ings of ourselves.
We might not have reached the ‘new’ para-
digm as yet. As Walker (2006) suggests the
sustainability movement is young. We are at
an evolutionary phase, “which embodies a
multitude of values and positions and a rec-
ognition of the uncertainty of the future and a
connection with the past” (Owen, 2003, p49).
This holistic conversion of the relationship
between science, philosophy and religion as
complementary modes of knowledge, indi-
cates a definite shift in which the experts need
to practice, from a narrow to broader domain.
2.1.2. Not All Experts Have What It Takes
The problems facing experts are complex
or, to use the term by Rittel and Webber
(1973), ‘wicked’. The implication is how or
who is to solve these problems? – we are
referring to sustainability-related problems
and concerns. Current professions do not
inspire confidence due to their reductionist
thinking and modes of problem solving and
because they operate within silos of interest
and knowledge areas.
Sustainability is an emergent property, re-
quiring a holistic perspective, which is in dy-
namic equilibrium with natural systems
(Pearce et al., 1989). It requires a co-created
learning systems (Laszlo, 2000) dynamic ap-
proach to address the unknown and emergent
nature of the issues where the problem
boundaries (Cilliers, 2001) are permeable and
dynamic.
In an analysis of the engineering profession
by Donnelly and Boyle (2006) in relation to
their ability to address sustainable develop-
ment issues, they identify the following as the
hindering factors (it is suggested here that this
critique applies to a range of experts):
• The solution space occurs at a local ‘pro-
ject’ level – implying a relatively impermea-
ble boundary (tending to operate in a
closed system view – limiting the scope and
other impacted systems);
• Assessment is done on short-term econom-
ics perspective;
• Problem framing and solution operates
from a specific knowledge paradigm;
• Engineers are considered expert problem
solvers, however, they are not known for
their problem seeking skills, especially
when crossing knowledge domains, such
as hard to soft systems or vice versa. Engi-
neers are equally not known for their skills
in assessing the impact of their solution
(while working on it) to the broader system
– they appear to be unable to dynamically
operate between the detail and at the
macro level – they operate well in one or
the other, but not simultaneously in both;
• Engineers are not apt at operating outside
the current social, political and institutional
arrangements, even though the true sus-
tainable solution will most likely be found
outside the prevailing paradigm;
• Another major issue lies within the educa-
tional system, which has been in place well
over 200 years “and is grounded in mathe-
matics and the physical sciences … [which]
is customized according to specific disci-
plines (i.e., civil, mechanical, chemical,
electrical, environmental, and software,
etc.)” (in Donnelly et al., 2006, p.152,
Mulder, 2004).
Wicked problems are not easily defined.
Their nature changes over time and they are
characterized by complex, interacting issues
that often emerge as a result of trying to de-
fine, understand and resolve the problem.
tripleC 8(1): 28-35, 2010 32
CC: Creative Commons License, 2010.
Every attempt to solve a wicked problem is
neither right nor wrong. What is important is
the solution and learning process that a team
will often cycle through in their attempts to
solve the wicked problem. This co-creation
process allows a team to understand the
causes of the wicked problem and explain it in
numerous ways (Neumeier, c2009`). The
effort must be multidisciplinary and over dif-
ferent time frames (short, medium and the
long view). The expert, as a product of a self-
serving knowledge paradigm, is not able to
rise above conventional priorities and busi-
ness norms, nor is the expert equipped to
cope with the demands called for to address
sustainable development. As Pink (2005)
describes, the left-brain is skilled and com-
fortable with linear and logical processes, a
good match to operate within the scientific
method, but not suited for the less structured
wicked problems of sustainability.
2.1.3. Design Thinking Is The Solution
Leadership, in ensuring that sustainable
development solutions are achieved, requires
more than technical know-how. People oper-
ating in this field require to be systemic think-
ers (Checkland, 1981), able to operate within
a learning system as the core of the problem
dynamic (in terms of change and uncertainty,
interaction with others, co-creation of knowl-
edge and perspectives) (Banathy, 1996).
They need to be comfortable with and ener-
gized by ambiguity, as well as ‘design wis-
dom’ (Nelson et al., 2003) as intentional ac-
tion of purpose and meaning.
If we look at the late Medieval and Renais-
sance period, we see the practice of solving
problems by using philosophy, art, science
and technology as an integrated holistic ap-
proach to address both clients’ and the com-
munity’s needs. The premise was humanistic
and responsive, being able to explore un-
known territory and shift perspective.
Pink (2005) suggests that we are entering
the ‘conceptual age’, where creativity, empa-
thy, intuition and the ability to ‘link seemingly
unrelated objects and events into something
new and different is important and necessary’.
Taking a closer look at the phrase above, he
is really expressing the essence of design
thinking and the abilities required to deal with
the complexity of sustainable development.
Pink’s description of the whole-brain ap-
proach captures the synthetic thinking pro-
cesses of the designer (for a more sophisti-
cated and detailed account refer to Nelson
and Stolterman (2003)). However, for the
purpose of this paper, Tim Brown’s (2008,
p87) and Pink’s (2005) less exhaustive de-
scription will be used:
• Empathy - viewing the world from multiple
perspectives – by taking a “people first” ap-
proach, design thinkers can imagine solu-
tions that are inherently desirable and meet
explicit or latent needs. Great design think-
ers observe the world in degrees of detail
and patterns. They notice things that others
do not and use their insights to inspire in-
novation;
• Integrative thinking – the whole-brain is
used, from analytical processes (either/or
choices) to both/and which can sometimes
appear to be contradictory aspects of a
confounding problem, thereby creating
novel solutions (see Roger Martin (2007)
for integrative thinking);
• Optimism – tolerance for ambiguity no
matter how challenging the constraints of a
problem might be;
• Experimentalism - significant innovations
don’t come from incremental tweaks. De-
sign thinkers pose questions and explore
constraints in creative ways that proceed in
entirely new directions;
• Collaboration - the complexity of problems
has replaced the myth of the lone creative
genius with the reality of the enthusiastic in-
terdisciplinary collaborator;
• Synthesis - seeing the big picture, crossing
boundaries and being able to combine dis-
parate pieces into a new whole;
• Meaning - purpose, transcendence and
spiritual fulfillment;
• Story Telling - the essence of persuasion,
communication and self-understanding has
become the ability to create a powerful nar-
rative.
The experts that have the skills and training
that best address the requirements for leading
sustainable development solutions are design
33 Rui H. Dos Santos Martin
CC: Creative Commons License, 2010.
thinkers. The skills described above are in
essence a description of a systems practi-
tioner - design thinking is systemic in nature.
All it would take is to train the design thinker in
the basic concepts and tools of systems prac-
tice, to leverage design’s core competency
and facilitate the emergence of sustained
development.
A second paper will explore a framework to
describe design thinking as an emergent
property resulting from the complex dynamics
of the problem space. This will be done by
drawing on the behavior of non-linear complex
adaptive systems as self-organizing emergent
nature at the edge of chaos and re-interpret
the design thinking process in a way which
encompasses the intuitive, non-linear and
qualitative way in which sustainable develop-
ment problems need to be addressed.
2.1.4. Final Thoughts
Currently, we have the technology that can
solve many issues that will address the envi-
ronmental problems that we are to face. What
we need is a radically different creative way to
make the changes we need – we need to
embrace the long view.
Our way of life has been reductive and
deeply analytical – manipulators of self-
serving knowledge. We are now shifting as a
society, pursuing purpose and meaning, with
a need to fill the spiritual vacuum created by
our materialistic values of single-minded and
selfish pursuit of capital. The age of abun-
dance has left us void of our essence of hu-
manity. We are now looking for something
else. The sustainable movement might just be
the symptom of the many issues that are con-
verging. The solution we need, will have to
address not only to save humanity from a
climatic catastrophe, but we also need
to relearn being holistic again. In the process,
we should not destroy the environment. This
realization that we should not destroy the
environment is something we forgot, since we
did destroy the environment in the past. We
must return to a holistic worldview.
We require ‘agents of change’. People who
can operate and solve problems by learning
their way into complex uncharted waters,
whilst taking full advantage of the shifts in the
market. We need people who can make
meaning and develop empathy for the broader
environment – social and physical. Our prod-
ucts and services need to be more than just
functional and cheap – they need to embody
our changing values and needs. We have not
been fulfilled by prosperity. The paradox of
prosperity is that while living standards have
increased, we are not happier as individuals,
families or as a society. That is why the mar-
ket which is slowly being liberated from mate-
rialism is now resolving the paradox, by
searching for meaning, and sustainability
might be that all encompassing representation
of a new paradigm. Andrew Delbanco (1999)
suggests that contemporary culture has lost
its purpose. It needs to rededicate itself to a
new story of transcendence.
People are seeking something - this
"something" is to have a sustainable society,
where the issues that are faced are not
treated in a "one-size fits all" attitude, but in-
stead, specific consideration
and recognition results in an understanding
that each situation is unique, since all con-
texts are different. This change
in understanding implies that recognition is
given to a set of values that were disregarded
or suppressed. Now these values play an
important role due to the chang-
ing attitudes towards the way we see the
world and our role in it. We have moved from
being ‘mechanistic’ to ‘human’, where altruis-
tic care (for the environment and other hu-
mans) is not selfish and only looking after the
self, but caring for others. This altruistic care
is important as it indicates the val-
ues underpinning the shift in atti-
tude required for sustainability to work.
3. Conclusion
The paper explored the nature of know-
ledge creation under the mechanistic para-
digm as reductionist and self-serving. Most
professionals/experts still operate under this
worldview.
By looking at the engineering profession as
an example, a detailed list describes why
most professionals are not able to operate in
a more complex and dynamic context required
by the problem space of sustainable devel-
opment.
tripleC 8(1): 28-35, 2010 34
CC: Creative Commons License, 2010.
The paper briefly surveys the literature to
describe the reasons for a shift from the
mechanistic worldview to the new era, which
has been described as ‘the conceptual age’.
This new worldview is driven in current society
by disillusion with materialism and the selfish
pursuit of capital.
The paper suggests that sustainable devel-
opment is systemic in nature and must be
approached by experts who are primarily sys-
tems thinkers. The proposal that design think-
ing is a naturally systemic process and these
experts should be leading in solving the
wicked problems of sustainable development
is the central focus of this paper.
References
Banathy, B. H. (1996). Designing social systems in a changing world. New York: Plenum Press.
Berman, M (1981). The Reenchantment of the World. Ithaca, London: Cornell University Press.
Bohm, D. & Hiley, B. J. (1993). The Undivided Universe: an ontological interpretation of quantum theory. London: Rout-
ledge.
Brown, T. (2008). Design Thinking. Harvard Business Review, 86 (6), 84-92.
Castro-Gomez, S. (2001). Traditional vs. Critical Cultural Theory. Cultural Critique, 49, 139-154.
Checkland, P. (1981). Systems thinking, systems practice. Chichester: Wiley.
Cilliers, P. (2001). Boundaries, Hierarchies and Networks in Complex Systems. International Journal of Innovation Man-
agement, 5 (2), 135-147.
Delbanco, A. (1999). The real American dream: a meditation on hope. Cambridge, London: Harvard University Press.
Dobson, A. (1996). Environment sustainabilities: An analysis and a typology. Environmental Politics, 5 (3), 401-428.
Donnelly, R. & Boyle, C. (2006). The Catch-22 of Engineering Sustainable Development. Journal of Environmental Engi-
neering, 132 (2), 149-155.
Foucault, M. & Gordon, C. (1980). Power/knowledge: selected interviews and other writings. 1972-1977. Brighton, Sussex:
Harvester Press.
Fox, W. (1990). Toward a Transpersonal Ecology: developing new foundations for environmentalism. Boston, Shambhala:
Random House.
Fry, T. (2006). Design, Ethics & Identity. Design Philosophy Papers. 1-12. [Online]. Available at:
http://www.desphilosophy.com/dpp/home.html (Accessed: 14 April 2009).
Goldsmith, E. (1988). Gaia: some implications of theoretical ecology. The Ecologist, 18 (2/3), 64-74.
Henry, J. (2008). The scientific revolution and the origins of modern science. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Jacobs, M. (1999) Sustainable development as a contested concept. In A. Dobson (Ed.), Fairness and futurity: essays on
environmental sustainability and social justice. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Kuhn, T. S., Conant, J. & Haugeland, J. (2000). The Road Since Structure: Philosophical Essays. 1970-1993. Chicago,
London: University of Chicago Press.
Laszlo, E. (1987). Evolution: the grand synthesis. Boston: New Science Library.
Laszlo, K. C. & Laszlo, A. (2000). 'Learning to Become: Creating Evolutionary Learning Community through Evolutionary
Systems Design'. A Coalition for Self-Learning. Available at:
http://www.creatinglearningcommunities.org/book/roots/laszlo2.htm (Accessed: 28 April 2009).
Leiss, W. (1994). The Domination of Nature. Montreal, Buffalo: McGill-Queen's University Press.
Lovelock, J. (2000). Homage to Gaia: the life of an independent scientist. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Martin, R. L. (2007). The Opposable Mind: how successful leaders win through integrative thinking. Boston: Harvard Busi-
ness School Press.
Merchant, C. (2005). Radical ecology: the search for a livable world. New York, London: Routledge.
Mitchell, C. (2000). Integrating Sustainability in Chemical Engineering Practice and Education: Concentricity and its Conse-
quences. Process Safety and Environmental Protection, 78 (4), 237-242.
Mulder, K. (2004). Engineering Education in Sustainable Development: sustainability as a tool to open up the windows of
engineering institutions. Business Strategy and the Environment, 13 (4), 275-285.
Naess, A. (1973). The shallow and the deep, long-range ecology movement. A summary. Inquiry, 16 (1), 95 - 100.
Nelson, H. G. & Stolterman, E. (2003). The Design Way: intentional change in an unpredictable world: foundations and
fundamentals of design competence. Englewood Cliffs: Educational Technology Publications.
Neumeier, M. (2009). The designful company: how to build a culture of nonstop innovation: a whiteboard overview. Ber-
keley: New Riders.
Owen, C. (2003). The Green field: the sub culture of sustainable architecture. PhD thesis: Melbourne University.
35 Rui H. Dos Santos Martin
CC: Creative Commons License, 2010.
Pearce, D. W., Markandya, A. & Barbier, E. B. (1989). Blueprint for a green economy. London: Earthscan.
Pink, D. H. (2005). A whole new mind: moving from the information age to the conceptual age. Crows Nest: Allen & Unwin.
Prigogine, I. & Stengers, I. (1984). Order out of Chaos: man's new dialogue with nature. Toronto, New York: Bantam Books.
Rittel, H. W. J. & Webber, M. M. (1973). Dilemmas in a General Theory of Planning. Policy Sciences. Elsevier, 4, 155-169.
Robertson, J. (1983). The Sane Alternative: a choice of futures. St. Paul: Minn.
Sagasti, F. R. (1990.) International cooperation in a fractured global order. Impact of Science on Society, 39 (3), 207-211.
Seitz, F. (1992). The science matrix: the journey, travails, triumphs. Springer.
Shapin, S. (1996). The Scientific Revolution. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Shapin, S. (2008). The Scientific Life: A Moral History of a Late Modern Vocation. Chicago, London: University of Chicago
Press.
Walker, S. (2006). Sustainable by design: explorations in theory and practice. London: Earthscan.
About the Author
Rui Martins is a design strategist and a consultant in team excellence and organizational training. With over 20 years’ expe-
rience, Rui approaches complex problems from the perspective of long-term sustainability. He has advised organizations on
the value of user-centered design and the creation of products/brands/services to improve the company’s ability to seize
new market opportunities. He is a passionate innovator with a proven ability to inspire and lead high-performance, cross-
disciplinary teams in the creation of groundbreaking solutions in complex environments. Rui has experience in a variety of
industries such as: Business & Strategy; Tourism; Construction; Architecture; Manufacturing; Central Government; Local
Government and Tertiary Education. Rui has won various awards and competitions in the design field and has published in
project management, organizational learning and complexity. He is company director for EarthPlea.