tripleC 7(2): 399-400, 2009
ISSN 1726-670X
http://www.triple-c.at
CC: Creative Commons License, 2009.
228
Conference Report: The Internet as Playground and Fac-
tory (November 12-14, 2009, The New School, New York
City, USA)
Christian Fuchs
University of Salzburg, Unified Theory of Information Research Group, http://fuchs.uti.at,
http://www.uti.at, christian.fuchs@sbg.ac.at,
everal hundred people attended the
conference ”The Internet as Playground
and Factory“ that took place from
November 12th-14th, 2009, and was orga-
nized by Trebor Scholz and his colleagues at
the New School in New York City (see
http://www.digitallabor.org).
The topic of the conference was that on the
Internet, and especially on what is by some
termed web 2.0, social software, or social
networking sites, play and labour tend to con-
verge and how this play-labour convergence
should be assessed.
Numerous scholars, activists, and artists
presented their works in 20 sessions. The
presented works can be situated within an
emerging transdisciplinary field that trans-
gresses the boundaries between the social
sciences and computer science and that has
been labelled with terms such as ICTs and
society, social informatics, information society
studies, Internet research, or new media &
society (compare: Christian Fuchs. 2008.
Introduction to the special issue on “ICTs and
society: PhD students’ transdisciplinary re-
search projects. tripleC 6(2): i-viii,
http://www.triple-
c.at/index.php/tripleC/article/view/80/74).
The methods used in the scholarly works
that were presented can in my opinion be
roughly divided into three types: First, the
narrative style: scholars who used this method
based their presentation on the discussion of
concrete examples for the Internet as play-
ground and/or factory and tended to discuss
quotations from various theories and ap-
proaches. This was the most frequently em-
ployed method of analysis. Second, theory
construction: some of the participants tried to
construct new theories of Internet labour
and/or Internet play that are grounded in exist-
ing theories and go beyond these theories.
Third, empirical research: others presented
results of case studies that were conducted by
employing data analysis or empirical social
research. Also any kind of combination of
these methods could be found at the confer-
ence.
“The Internet as Playground and Factory”
has shown that the field of ICTs and society is
continuously growing in size and importance,
that this field has also created a multiplicity of
critical approaches, and that it is important
and promising that critical Internet studies are
further pursued and advanced.
If the Internet is a playground and/or a fac-
tory and what kind of Internet is desirable are
highly normative and political questions that
were at the heart of the discussions at the
conference. This political dimension is also
related to the question to which extent the
contemporary Internet is or is not a democ-
ratic space, which democratic and anti-
democratic potentials are inherent in the inter-
relation of the contemporary Internet and con-
temporary society, and which strategies for
political transformation make sense and
should be employed in this context.
In my opinion, three positions on these
questions could be identified in the presenta-
tions and discussions at the conference.
These positions partly overlap, are partly
complementary, but to a certain extent also
stand in contradiction to each other.
Representatives of the first position hold
that there is a symmetric exchange between
tripleC 7(2): 399-400, 2009 400
CC: Creative Commons License, 2009.
users and Internet companies so that the lat-
ter make money profits and in exchange pro-
vide benefits in the form of free access for
users to technologies that allow information
sharing, communication, and community
building. The Internet is conceived in this posi-
tion as being a participatory system because it
allows users to become information producers
and to create and share user-generated con-
tent. Representatives of the second position
tend to argue that the Internet is not a truly
democratic or participatory space, but has
deficiencies and is shaped by asymmetric
power structures. However, there would be
democratic projects and potentials of the In-
ternet that allow envisioning the realization of
an alternative, people-centred Internet. The
representatives of this position are thus rather
optimistic and argue that projects such as for
example peer-to-peer platforms, open access,
open content, free software, open source,
alternative online media, digital art projects,
cyberprotest, public online media, public ac-
cess projects, etc are likely to bring about
positive changes. Representatives of the third
position see the Internet as being shaped by
asymmetric power relations. They tend to
argue that there are positive potentials and
projects for an alternative participatory Inter-
net, but that the contemporary Internet is
largely shaped by powerful actors, especially
corporations, that derive material benefits at
the expense of Internet users, commodify the
Internet, exploit Internet users, and appropri-
ate the Internet commons. Categories em-
ployed in this context include exploitation,
class, capitalism, alienation, enclosure, ap-
propriation, or expropriation. The political im-
plication of this position is that political move-
ments and organizations are needed that
bring about wider transformations of society
so that a commons-based and participatory
Internet becomes possible.
These three positions on the one hand
partly overlap or are simultaneously present in
approaches, and on the other hand are to a
certain degree opposites that result from dif-
ferent political and theoretical positions. Op-
posites need not and cannot always be over-
come, it is possible that they stand side by
side and create productive tensions that ad-
vance the overall field. This requires to ac-
knowledge that there are certain commonali-
ties and to agree that there are disagree-
ments.
Overall, the conference “The Internet as
Playground and Factory” has shown that Criti-
cal Internet Studies is alive and well and is a
subfield that is growing in size and importance
of the transdiscipline ICTs and society. The
practical hope for the future is that Internet
scholars will continue to work in the critical
spirit that has shaped this conference and
thereby will try to contribute to bring about a
participatory Internet in a participatory society.
Conference links
Conference web site: http://www.digitallabor.org
Twitter: http://twitter.com/idctweets
Conference Twitter hashtag: #IPF09
Flickr: http://www.flickr.com/photos/newschool/collections/72157600533401886/
Vimeo: http://vimeo.com/user2103510/videos/sort:date
Conference video streams: http://streamingculture.parsons.edu/
Mailing list: http://digitallabor.org/discussion