tripleC 7(1): 88-93, 2009
ISSN 1726-670X
http://www.triple-c.at
CC: Creative Commons License, 2009.
The Convergence of the Codex Book and the e-Book
Robert K. Logan
Ontario College of Art and Design, Toronto, Canada; logan@physics.utoronto.ca
Abstract: We are proposing a platform for a new form of the book, the sBook, which is a
combination of the codex book and the e-book. The sBook combines the advantages of these two
formats of the book as well as some additional features that we have designed for this new hybrid
book. We describe one possible form of an sBook, which is a codex book that has been “smart
tagged” so that the book directs one’s Enabler to a Web site that contains the digital form of the
text of the codex book. The Enabler could be a desktop or notebook computer, a PDA or a smart
phone such as the iPhone. As a result the sBook system - consisting of the codex book, the
Enabler, and the Web site - is readable, searchable, networkable, updatable, smart and promotes
“active reading”. The book is very readable because the sBook still retains the codex format of ink
on paper. Because the “smart tag” directs the reader to a Web site with the digital text and room for
comments by readers and updates by the author, the sBook is searchable, networkable and
updatable. Finally by incorporating a recommender system installed on the Enabler the sBook can
match its content to that of the reader’s research and information interests. The recommender
system can also search the Net for pertinent information. This paper explores some of the possible
applications of the sBook and its impact on authors, readers, publishers, booksellers and libraries.
Keywords: book, sBook, smart, “active reading”, booksellers, publishers, libraries, searchable
Acknowledgement: The sBook was first conceived at the Strategic Innovation Lab (formerly the
Beal Institute of Strategic Creativity) at the Ontario College of Art and Design in 2005 and is
headed by the co-PIs RKL and Greg Van Alstyne. We wish to acknowledge the support of the
Lab’s director, Lenore Richards and the contributions that have been made to developing the
SmartBook idea by the project team consisting of James Caldwell, Dave Gray, Peter Jones, Kathy
Kawasaki, Gale Moore, Matt Ratto, Ramon Sangüesa, and Carlos Scolari.
1. Starting Idea
group of researchers at the Strategic
Innovation Lab at the Ontario College or
Art and Design headed by Greg Van
Alstyne and Robert K. Logan are proposing a
new format or platform for books that
combines the best features of a codex book
and an e-book. One form of the sBook we are
considering would use a smart tag, which
could be a bar code, a QR code or an RFID
tag depending on the application, with a
standard printed codex or folio book that
points one’s Enabler to a Web site that has
the text of the book in a digital format. The
Enabler could be a desktop or notebook
computer, a PDA or a smart phone such as
the iPhone. The resulting hybrid book, which
we call an sBook, combines the features and
advantages of a codex book and an e-book as
well as the added feature of a recommender
system that is to be embedded in the Enabler.
As a consequence the sBook is readable,
searchable, networkable, smart and promotes
“active reading”.
The sBook is readable because of its codex
format and the fact that ink on paper is the
best way to read text. It is searchable
because the smart tag points to a digital form
of the book’s content on a Web site. It is
networkable because the Web site containing
the digital form of the book is to be used for
tripleC 7(1): 88-93, 2009 89
CC: Creative Commons License, 2009.
readers to share ideas about the book with
each other and the author as is done on a
blog. The author can comment on the readers’
remarks and also update her book either on
the basis of readers’ comments or because of
new developments in the field of study that
the book addresses. Finally, the book is smart
because it knows what the reader wants to
know and it can recommend what parts of the
book are of particular interest to the reader
through the recommender system embedded
in the Enabler. The recommender system has
a profile of the reader’s research needs and
information interests and has an internal and
an external component. The internal
recommender system is able to highlight
those portions of the book that will be of
particular interest to the reader. The external
recommender system would be largely Web
based and would bring information external to
the book to the attention of the reader. The
Enabler and the Web site with the digital text
would also have tools to facilitate active
reading consisting of the following activities:
“annotating, quoting, comparing, searching,
taking notes, sharing” as described in detail
by Gene Golovchinsky (www.fxpal.com/
publications/FXPAL-PR-08-468.pdf) in his
article Reading in The Office (see also
www.zenguide.co.uk/2008/05/going-shelfless/
for more on active reading.
The sBook system also allows a codex
book to incorporate the advantages of
hypertext through the Web interface. One
would read the codex book with one’ Enabler
close at hand. The author could indicate
places in the codex text where one could jump
to another part of the book or to another
source of information on the Web, which the
reader of the codex form of the book could
access with their Enabler through the Web
and thereby enrich their reading experience.
The text that will be hypertexted in the digital
version of the book can be indicated in the
printed book by using a special font to indicate
where the hypertext link can be found in the
digital version of the book.
Our proposal is not the first example of a
system that combines a codex book with a
digital form of the text. There are for example
many textbooks that come with a CD-ROM
containing the digital version of the book.
Amazon has an Upgrade feature which allows
a reader to access an electronic version of the
book they order on the Internet for a selected
number of books. It also allows the reader to
add highlights, bookmarks, notes or tags to
any page in the book. Norton publishers have
a series of textbooks that they offer in a
standard codex form with access to a digital
version of the book and an electronic
workbook (SmartWork). They also offer the e-
book version of their textbook for
approximately half the price of the codex
version of the book. O’Reilly Media offers a
number of their books in a print version, an e-
book version and a bundled package of the
two formats. Their e-book version comes in
three digital formats, PDF, ePub and
Mobipocket (for Kindle users).
The SmartBook system that we have just
described should be regarded as SmartBook
1.0 and is presented as a scenario to help the
reader imagine how some combination of a
codex book and an e-book could create a
reading system that has the best of both
platforms. We are still in the midst of our
research to design a platform that is a hybrid
of the codex book and the e-book that will
satisfy the needs, desires, expectations and
latent behaviours of 21
st
century readers. This
is a progress report of work in progress.
What makes our sBook proposal different is
that it incorporates so many useful features
with the potential to change:
• the operations of libraries,
• the operations of bookstores,
• the operations of publishers,
• the way in which books are kept up to date,
• the way in which the book can become the
focus of a social network,
• the way active reading is pursued,
• the way knowledge is shared,
• the way elearning operates, and
• the way researchers can more efficiently find
the information they need for their projects
without reading the whole book.
Our research agenda is to consider all
possible configurations of sBooks and match
them with possible applications in the future
that tap into the needs, desires, expectations,
and latent behaviours of potential readers and
users. In this paper we will report on our
preliminary progress in carrying out this
agenda and describe a publishing project that
tripleC 7(1): 88-93, 2009 90
CC: Creative Commons License, 2009.
will test the networking and upgrading
features of an sBook. Our objective is not to
design a device but rather a platform. The
description of the device, which uses a tag to
link with a Web, is used to give the reader a
notion of the kind of platform we have in mind.
It is basically a scenario to help us envisage
the kind of platform we would like to develop
and what properties we would like that
platform to possess.
2. A New Option for Publishers
The sBook represents a third option for book
publishers in addition to the standard printed
codex book (option 1), and the various digital
formats of the book such as an e-book or a
book on a CD-ROM (option 2). Options 1 and
2 have their unique advantages. The chief
advantage of the printed codex or folio book is
that it is the best form yet devised for
readability. The codex format is also better
suited for quickly browsing the book to get the
feel for it especially if the book has a detailed
table of contents and index and is written so
that the contents of the book are summarized
in the first few pages of the book. The
advantage of the digital book, on the other
hand, is that it is the format of choice for
searching, researching and engaging in active
reading. The e-book has the advantage that
for a complex subject one can easily search
the content of the book for topics of particular
interest to the reader and thereby tie together
related themes. This is particularly true if the
e-book is written taking advantage of
hypertext.
The sBook has all the advantages of both
options 1 and 2 and in addition it can
customize the content of the book for the
specific use of the reader and it can create a
forum for the discussion of the book. These
features are particularly useful for books that
are written and used for research. There is
less of a need for the searchability of the
sBook format for a novel or a book of poetry
unless that book is a classic that is frequently
studied by scholars and students. But even for
books that are purely literary the ability of
readers to network with each other and
possibly the author could be a distinct
advantage.
If the sBooks succeed in penetrating the
market they will have an enormous impact of
book publishing, booksellers, libraries and
schools. Book publisher will not only have to
print and distribute codex books they will also
have to maintain a Web site for each book
they publish.
As the number of sBooks increases there
will be an impact on libraries. Imagine a library
of sBooks in which a user enters with their
recommender system on their Enabler and
are directed to those volumes that are of most
interest to them. Part of the function of the
reference librarian will be taken over by the
sBook. The library edition of the sBook will
have to have a RFID tag that can transmit a
radio signal over a long distance.
The sBooks will also impact bookstores.
Imagine walking into a bookstore with one’s
Enabler with an embedded recommender
system and being directed to the books one
would want to buy. How convenient!
3. A New Option for Authors
Printed books have been limited to text and
pictures (illustrations, photographs and
reproduction of fine art). With the sBook
platform a whole new world opens up
because the ability to use hypertext links to
the Web site associated with the book as
described above to enrich the text and
illustrations of the printed book. In addition to
text and illustrations the author can now add
video and audio files to enrich the traditional
content of a printed book. When we first
conceived the sBook project we thought that
fictional sBooks would not be of much interest
but as a result of a number of fiction authors
we met at the BookCampTO held in Toronto
June 6, 2009 we discovered there is an
interest in creative writers to take advantage
of the features of the sBook platform to create
a new kind of art form, a novel or a short story
that incorporates in the text pictorial elements,
video clips and audio bites. We also found a
publisher interested in publishing in this
format. This is very exciting – the notion of
creating a new art form on the sBook platform,
a mashup of text, pictures, video and audio!!
tripleC 7(1): 88-93, 2009 91
CC: Creative Commons License, 2009.
4. Laws of the Media (LOM)
To gain a deeper insight into the nature of the
codex book and the sBook that we are
proposing let us apply McLuhan’s (McLuhan
1975 & McLuhan and McLuhan 1988) Laws of
the Media (LOM) for these two media.
LOM consist of the following four laws:
1. Every medium or technology
enhances some human function.
2. In doing so, it obsolesces some
former medium or technology, which was
used to achieve the function earlier.
3. In achieving its function, the new
medium or technology retrieves some older
form from the past.
4. When pushed far enough, the new
medium or technology reverses or flips into a
complementary form.
4.1. LOM Codex Book
Enhances: the storage of and access to
information
Obsolesces: oral tradition or myths
Retrieves: memory
Flips into: e-book
4.2. LOM sBook
Enhances: the codex book and hence
readability, searchability, relevance, currency,
active reading
Obsolesces: the traditional library and the
manual search
Retrieves: the reference librarian and the
book club
Flips into: the smart library and the online
symposium
5. Protecting Copyright
In order to fulfill all the functions of the sBook
that we have identified such as their use in a
library or their availability at a bookstore and
still protect the copyright of the authors the
sBook will have to have three levels of
access:
1. The privately owned version - The owner
of the book can read the book in the
traditional manner and also capture the data
in the book electronically and transform it at
will. They will be able to create a personal
searchable library with a smart catalog from
their collection of sBooks.
2. The library version – The library patrons
will be able to read the book in hard copy
and/or access the entire book electronically,
which will allow them to search for and access
items of interest in the sBook without having
to read the entire book. This will facilitate a
great deal of library research as scholars will
be able to quickly access the material they
need by organizing Google-like searches.
They will be restricted, however, from the
wholesale copying of the contents of the book
onto their SB Reader or any third medium. A
certain number of lines of text for the purpose
of quoting will be allowed depending on the
discretion of the publisher and the author.
3. The bookstore version – While the book
sits in a bookstore before it is purchased it will
be searchable but not copy-able. A collection
of sBooks in the bookstore will allow
customers to find a book or books that meet
their interest and describe to them where in
the store they may find them. They will be
able to access the book electronically but they
will not be able to copy any of the pages of
the book except promotional pages at the
discretion of the publisher and the author.
5. sBook Applications
In this section we describe a number of
potential uses or application that can be made
with the sBook system.
5.1. Other media
We begin by noting that the use of the sBook
platform is not limited to books as one might
wish to consider smart journals, smart
magazines, and smart newspapers. Some
features of a smart journal already exist as
some journals are published in both a print
and a digital form with space reserved in the
digital form for reader comments. Most online
versions of newspapers have a mechanism
for reader comments but unfortunately they
tripleC 7(1): 88-93, 2009 92
CC: Creative Commons License, 2009.
are too often used for flaming or promoting a
particular political point of view rather than
being used for entering into constructive
serious dialogues.
5.2. Print-on-demand
A number of out of print book have been
scanned by the Gutenberg Project, the Million
Books Project and Google. It would be a real
service to scholarship if some of these books
could be offered in a bundle of the digital
version and the print version produced by a
print-on-demand (POD) service. Publishers
might also wish to make their out of print
books available in a digital/POD bundle.
Smart libraries – Imagine students and
research faculty using their Enabler at their
library’s information commons to find the
research material for their various projects.
6. A Partial Prototype
Two of the features of the sBook will be tested
when my book Understanding New Media:
Extending Marshall McLuhan, an update of
McLuhan’s Understanding Media: Extensions
of Man is released in the summer of 2009. A
Web site will be created that readers of the
book will be directed to so that they can leave
comments, which I may choose to respond to
in the spirit of a blog. I will also use this Web
site to continually update my book.
7. Does the sBook System Actually
Require the Incorporation of the
Printed Book?
There is a division of opinion among members
of our research team and those who have
commented on our project as to whether or
not the format of the printed book will
ultimately survive. Many believe that the
printed book will basically be eclipsed by the
e-book and that it will be relegated to special
uses, as is the case of the scroll, which plays
a central role in the weekly, or thrice weekly
reading of the Torah in synagogues
throughout the world. They argue that the e-
book is just as easy to read as a printed book
and that it is an extremely convenient medium
especially when stored on an e-book reader
because one can access hundreds of books
without having the problem of porting and
storing them.
I personally am of the opinion that the
printed book will survive because it is still the
best medium for close and careful reading.
When I asked a group of authors at
BookCampTO whether they edit their word-
processed texts on paper or on a screen all
25 who responded said they edited their final
version on paper. The same was true a group
of 17 academic writers at the Media Ecology
Association conference. One writer, however,
said that she found that she caught some
errors on screen that she did not catch on
paper and vice-versa. I believe the reason
that writers favour paper for editing over the
screen is that they can focus better with ink on
paper rather than with pixels on a screen.
The reason for this preference can be
explained in terms of our bicameral brain. We
use the left side of our brain for language
activities like speaking, writing and reading
and we use the right side of our brain for
visual and musical activities. When one reads
on a screen one first uses the right brain to
integrate the pixels into a gestalt that is then
read by the left-brain so there is a lot of traffic
flowing through the corpus collosum. A reader
reading ink on paper only needs to use their
left brain and therefore is less distracted and
hence more focused.
I do not pretend that all readers will be
convinced by this argument but we can all
agree that the printed codex book will be
around for quite a long time. But more
importantly as many have pointed out it is not
always necessary for the printed book to be
part of the sBook platform. One could well
imagine a publisher publishing an e-book part
using the features of the sBook platform to
take advantage of the way the Web site
becomes an extension of the book through its
features of social networking, author updates,
“active reading,” and its capability of creating
new forms of hybrid text that incorporate video
or audio clips. Publishers of e-books could
also add a feature to their e-book that allows
the purchasers of the e-book to make use of a
print-on-demand device to create a hard copy
of the book should they so desire.
tripleC 7(1): 88-93, 2009 93
CC: Creative Commons License, 2009.
8. An Invitation
To conduct our sBook research we have
created a Google Group discussion group
called Rethinking the Book. Readers of this
article interested in joining our Rethinking the
Book Google discussion group should email
me at logan@physics.utoronto.ca and they
will be included in the group.