
tripleC 7(2): 142-157, 2009 145
CC: Creative Commons License, 2009.
improve it can never succeed. Although it is
useful to know that we should stop trying to fix
this approach and start looking for a different
one, the disappointing conclusion is that, as
far as question (b) above is concerned, we
lack even a promising strategy to upgrade I
a
p
to K
a
p.
So much regarding (b), which we can now
leave on one side. Prospects are much
brighter when it comes to question (a). In this
case, the challenge is not a shortage, but
rather an overabundance of viable answers,
since we are spoiled for choice by a variety of
theories of truth.
7
Admittedly, in the literature
on semantic information there appears to be
at least an implicit predilection for some
version of a Tarskian and/or correspondentist
approach.
8
And yet, at least in principle,
nothing prevents each of the major theories of
truth from answering (a). They simply would
have been refuted a long time ago if they
couldn’t. It follows that some initial tolerance
towards a pluralistic approach to (a) might be
unavoidable, if not methodologically welcome.
Of course, if this were all that one could
sensibly recommend about (a), there would
be little reason to pursue any further
investigation. There is, however, another way
of approaching (a), which opens up an
interesting line of enquiry.
Consider the strategy sketched above. It
consists in selecting the best available theory
of truth and testing how well it might be
applied and adapted in order to explain the
truthfulness of semantic information. With
some negligible adjustments, such a top-down
approach is comparable to the so-called
“design pattern” technique (Gamma et al.
(1995)) in software engineering (Sommerville
(2007)). This consists in identifying and
specifying the abstract features of a design
structure, which are then generally reusable
solutions to commonly occurring problems in
the construction of an artefact. In our case, we
have several design patterns for the concept
of truth. We know that they are robust,
7
In this paper, I have relied especially on Lynch
(2001), Engel (2002) and Künne (2003), among the many
introductions and anthologies available on the major
theories of truth, as particularly helpful.
8
See for example Popper (1935), Dretske (1981), Fox
(1983), Israel and Perry (1990), Barwise and Seligman
(1997) and Bremer and Cohnitz (2004).
because they have been tested and refined
since Ramsey, if not Aristotle. We also know
that they are reusable: although they have
been developed to deal primarily with
propositional or sentential truths, one may
reasonably expect them to be effectively
adaptable to truthful data (e.g. a truthful map)
as well. So, when our artefact, i.e. semantic
information, is proved to require the particular
feature of being truthful, a sensible alternative
is to consider such design patterns and try to
identify the ones that best satisfy the
constraints and requirements imposed by the
development of the artefact itself.
Oversimplifying, one may answer (a) by
choosing whichever pre-packaged theory of
truth turns out to be most suitable. This
strategy may be classic, is certainly viable but
it is hardly innovative and I shall not pursue it
in the following pages.
The other approach is bottom-up and
suggests the sort of strategy that will guide
the rest of this investigation. It consists in
assuming the artefact itself as given, and then
trying to discover the principles governing its
properties and workings by analysing its
structure, function and operations. In software
engineering, this technique is known as
“reverse engineering”. This is “the process of
extracting the knowledge or design blueprints
from anything man-made” (Eilam (2005), p.
3). It consists in examining an existing artefact
in order to identify its components and their
interrelationships and hence create
representations of it in other forms or at a
higher level of generalization. Following this
strategy, one may answer question (a) by
assuming the occurrence of some semantic
information and then disassembling it in order
to reveal what its components are and how
they interact with each other to deliver
information. We have the artefact and we
seek to understand its mechanism by taking it
apart, hopefully in the right way and places.
Note that this second strategy is perfectly
compatible with the first, once it is realised
that there is a virtuous cycle of feedback
between design patterns and reverse
engineering results. Contrary to the first
strategy, however, reverse engineering
promises to deliver a more innovate analysis,
as it avoids approaching the problem of truth
from pre-established theories and explores it